The Best Italian Near Islip, NY

Italian food has a longer history than the nation, and it varies even in different regions in Italy. So you can taste the flavor of history from every bite of Italian food. When it comes Italian food, we have a lot more choices than just spaghetti and pizza. Italians are known to be serious with their food, and it is featured with its simple but high-quality ingredients. Italian cooks are particular about heat control to keep the food's original flavor. From hearty lasagna to saucy Orecchiette, these easy, comforting classics can win your heart any day of the week.

Popular Italian Restaurants

• 

  Bayberry Cafe

  4.0 based on 115 votes

  Italian

  Get Locations

  • View All »
• 

  Gino's Tuscany

  4.4 based on 112 votes

  Italian

  Get Locations

  • Mozzarella Sticks$5.95
  • Green House Salad$4.95 - $6.95
  • Soup$5.95
  • Garlic Knots (1/2 Doz)$2.75
  • Garlic Knots (1 Doz)$4.50
  • Garlic Bread$2.95
  • View All »
• 

  The Gatsby

  4.1 based on 117 votes

  Italian

  Get Locations

  • Apple Cobbler Vanilla Ice Cream$8.00
  • Creme Brulee$8.00
  • Chocolate Souffle Cake$8.00
  • Homemade Tiramisu$8.00
  • Basmati Rice Pudding$7.00
  • Ice Cream & Sorbets$6.00
  • View All »
• 

  Nico at the Gatsby Mansion

  4.2 based on 63 votes

  Italian

  Get Locations

  • Mozzarella Con Prosciutto$12.00
  • Insalata Di Mare$15.00
  • Cocktail Di Gamberoni$14.00
  • Apple Cobbler$8.00
  • Creme Brulee$8.00
  • Molten Chocolate Cake$8.00
  • View All »
• 

  Da Noi Italian Restaurant

  4.0 based on 144 votes

  Italian

  Get Locations

  • Calamari Fritti$12.00
  • Vongole Casino$12.00
  • Involtini di Melanzane$12.00
  • Carpaccio Di Manzo$15.00
  • Torre Di Bufala$16.00
  • Zuppa D'aragosta$10.00
  • View All »