Menu With Price Menu Hagar's Manhattan Deli Menu

Hagar's Manhattan Deli Menu and Prices

4.1 based on 66 votes

Choose My State

Salads

All salads are homemade:

Potato Salad	$1.25 - $3.95
Macaroni Salad	$1.25 - $3.95
Coleslaw	$1.25 - $3.95
Baked Beans	$1.25 - $3.95
Italian Pasta Salad (8 oz.)	$1.50	Seasonal tomato & olive salad MORE

Soups

Homemade every day

Cheese	0	$2.59 - $4.48
Chicken Noodle	0	$2.59 - $4.48
Mild Chili	0	$2.59 - $4.48
Freds	0	$2.59 - $4.48

Hoagies

Ham	0	$5.45 - $8.50	Cotto salami, bologna, american cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo & oil dressing on a hoagie bun. MORE

Turkey Ham	0	$5.45 - $8.50	Cotto salami, swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo & oil dressing on a hoagie bun.. MORE
The Zach Johnson	0	$5.45 - $8.50	Ham, hard salami, pepperoni, provolone & hot pepper cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo & oil dressing on a hoagie bun. MORE
Roast Beef Cheddar & Provolone Cheese	0	$5.45 - $8.50	Lettuce, tomato, onion, pepper rings, mayo & oil dressing on a hoagie bun. MORE
Oven Roasted Turkey & Pepperoni	0	$5.45 - $8.50	Cheddar cheese, lettuce, italian salsa, mayo & oil dressing on a hoagie bun. MORE
Smoked Turkey & Smoked Cheddar	0	$5.45 - $8.50	Lettuce, tomato, mayo, oil dressing on a hoagie bun. MORE
Ham, American Cheese	0	$5.45 - $8.50	Lettuce, tomato, mayo, & ranch dressing on a hoagie bun. MORE

Quick & Easy

Ham	0	$4.25	Ham with mustard, pickle, mayo, lettuce on white or wheat bread. MORE
Turkey	0	$4.25	Turkey with mustard, pickle, mayo, lettuce on white or wheat bread. MORE
Roast Beef	0	$4.50	Roast beef with mustard, pickle, mayo, lettuce on white or wheat bread. MORE
Corned Beef	0	$4.75	Corned beef with mustard, pickle, mayo, lettuce on white or wheat bread. MORE

Smoked Turkey	0	$4.50	Smoked turkey with mustard, pickle, mayo, lettuce on white or wheat bread. MORE
Egg Salad	0	$3.80	Egg salad with lettuce & tomato on white or wheat bread. MORE
Tuna Salad	0	$4.25	Tuna salad with lettuce & tomato, on white or wheat bread. MORE
Egg Supreme	0	$4.75	Egg salad with lettuce, tomato, swiss cheese on a hoagie bun. MORE
Tuna Supreme	0	$5.20	Tuna salad with lettuce, tomato, swiss cheese on a hoagie bun. MORE
Tuna Supreme	0	$5.20	Tuna salad with lettuce, tomato, swiss cheese on a hoagie bun. MORE
Chicken Salad	0	$5.20	Chicken salad with lettuce, tomato on white or wheat bread. MORE

Warm Italian Subs

VIT0	0	$5.45	Italian beef, provolone, mild peppers with mustard & mayo on a hoagie bun. Switch to mix peppers for $0.50 extra or hot peppers for $0.75 extra. MORE
Little Italy	0	$6.40	Pastrami & hard salami with provolone, swiss, onion, mild fried peppers, brown mustard, mayo, seasoning & oil dressing on a hoagie bun. MORE
Wise Guy	0	$5.45	Oven roasted turkey, capicola, pepperoni, hot pepper cheese, pepper rings, mayo & dijon on a hoagie bun. MORE

Mama Mia	0	$6.40	Capicola, italian beef, pepperoni, hot pepper cheese, provolone cheese, mild fried peppers & red roasted peppers with mayo, oil & seasoning on a hoagie bun. MORE
Mitchs 3 Alarm	0	$6.40	Roast beef & pepperoni with hot pepper cheese, mixed fried peppers, pepper rings & mayo on a hoagie bun. MORE
Bambino	0	$5.45	Capicola, hard salami, pepperoni, provolone cheese, italian salsa, mayo & oil dressing on a hoagie bun. MORE

Vegetarians

Veggie Reuben	$4.95	Provolone, swiss, pepper cheese, sauerkraut, pickles, onions, green peppers, brown mustard, thousand island dressing on rye bread. Warmed MORE
Cheese Supreme	$4.95	Provolone, cheddar & hot pepper cheese, lettuce, tomato, green pepper, mustard, mayo & pickle on a hoagie bun. Warmed MORE
Veggie	$5.45	Lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, green pepper, mild fried peppers, coleslaw, american & provolone cheese, mayo & oil dressing on a hoagie bun. Cold MORE

Warm Originals

Manhattan	0	$5.45	Corn beef, ham, salami, coleslaw & swiss with mustard, mayo & pickle on an onion bun. MORE
Charlies	0	$4.95	Ham, turkey & swiss with mustard, mayo & pickle on an onion bun. MORE
Bettys	0	$4.95	Turkey, salami & pepper cheese with mustard, mayo & pickle on an onion bun. MORE
The Brianna	0	$4.95	Turkey, roast beef & provolone with mustard, mayo & pickle on an onion bun. MORE

Reuben	0	$5.45	Corned beef with swiss, sauerkraut, pickle & 1000 island dressing on rye. MORE
Hotn Spicy	0	$4.95	Pepperoni & pepper cheese with brown mustard & pickle on rye. MORE
Big Smoker	0	$4.95	Bar-B-Q beef with smoked cheddar cheese on a hoagie bun. MORE
Deli Burger	0	$4.95	Roast beef, cheddar cheese, mustard, pickle, mayo, ketchup & onion on an onion bun. MORE
Liberty	0	$4.95	Turkey & pepperoni, american cheese, brown mustard, mayo, onion & pickle on an onion bun. MORE
Truly Delicious	0	$6.40	Italian beef turkey, cream cheese, cheddar cheese, pepper rings & mayo on a hoagie bun. MORE
Susie	0	$4.95	Open face bagel with cream cheese topped with your choice of meat & pickle. MORE
Bagel Cream Cheese	0	$1.50

Cold Originals

Brooklyn B	0	$4.95	Turkey, hard salami with cheddar, mayo, lettuce & tomato on white bread. MORE
Big G	0	$4.95	Italian roast beef & smoked turkey with provolone, brown mustard, mayo & lettuce on wheat bread. MORE

Holiday Turkey	0	$4.95	Oven roasted turkey, mustard, mayo, lettuce, tomato & american cheese on white bread. MORE
Time Square	0	$5.45	Roast beef or turkey with swiss, coleslaw & 1000 island dressing on a hoagie bun. MORE
Double Decker	0	$6.40	Choice of meat and bread with mustard, mayo, oil dressing, lettuce & tomato, swiss & american cheese. MORE
Pita Supreme	0	$4.95	Choice of meat with lettuce, tomato, swiss cheese, mayo, mustard & oil dressing on a folded pita bread. MORE
Corned Beef Deluxe	0	$5.45	Mustard, pickle, mayo, swiss, coleslaw, & fried peppers on rye. MORE

Sides

Chips	$1.25
Pickles	$1.25
7 Layer Bars	$1.75
Cookies	$1.25
Brownies	$1.50
Scotcheroos	$1.50	When available MORE
Pecan Bars	$2.00

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.