Jay's Deli Prices in Highland Mills, NY 10930
Hours of Operation
-
Hours may fluctuate. For detailed hours of operation, please contact the store directly.
Restaurant Menu
| Appetizers |
| For when you just want something to nibble |
| Jalapeno Poppers | $6.99 |
With choice of sauce
0
|
| Onion Rings | $3.99 |
0
|
| Mozzarella Sticks | $4.99 |
With jay's marinara
0
|
| Sample Platter | $6.99 |
3 ravioli, 2 poppers, 3 sticks and 2 fingers, served with choice of sauce
0
|
| 4 Pieces Chicken Fingers | $4.99 |
Regular or hot
0
|
| 4 Pieces Chiken Fingers with Fries | $6.99 |
Regular or hot
0
|
| Popcorn Chicken | $4.95 |
With choice of sauce
0
|
| French Fries | $2.99 |
0
|
| Fried Ravioli | $3.99 |
With jay's marinara
0
|
| 10 Pieces Chicken Wings | $8.99 |
Mild, medium, hot, honey BBQ, sesame ginger, BBQ, garlic parm
0
|
| 6 Pieces Chicken Fingers | $6.99 |
Regular or hot
0
|
| Garden Salads |
| Small Tossed Salad | $3.59 |
Fresh garden greens with choice of dressing
0
|
| Caesar Salad | $5.99 |
Hearts of romaine with a creamy caesar dressing
0
|
| Large Tossed Salad | $5.99 |
Fresh garden greens with choice of dressing
0
|
| Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad | $7.99 |
Chicken, hearts of romaine and crreamy caesar dressing
0
|
| Small Chef Salad | $5.99 |
Our green salad wit sliced cold cuts and cheese, served with choice of dressing. Add grilled chicken to any salad $2.00
0
|
| Large Chef Salad | $7.99 |
Our garden salad with sliced cold cuts and cheese. Add grilled steak or shrimp to any salad $3.00
0
|
| Soups |
| Gumbos and chowders prepared fresh daily |
| Small Chili | $4.95 |
Our secret recipe
0
|
| Large Chili | $6.95 |
Our secret recipe
0
|
| Pizzas |
| Home of the 18 inch pizza. Each specialty topping for whole pizza: $3.00 bacon, ham, eggplant, broccoli, hot or sweet peppers, spinach, sun-dried tomato, roasted peppers. Each extra filling for cheese calzone $1.50 |
| Cheese Pizza | $14.00 |
0
|
| Sicilian Pizza | $16.00 |
0
|
| Chicken Slice | $3.50 |
0
|
| Cheese Calzone | $6.99 |
Generous portion of ricotta and mozzarella cheese with jay's tomato sauce on the side
0
|
| Family Size Calzone | $12.99 |
This thing feeds a small army
0
|
| Garlic Knots (6) | $2.50 |
$0.50 each
0
|
| Slice | $2.25 |
0
|
| Sicilian Slice | $3.00 |
0
|
| Specialty Slice | $3.50 |
0
|
| Topping Selections |
Each extra filling for family size calzone $2.99. Each topping for whole pizza $2.00 extra cheese, mushrooms, sausage, meatballs, pepperoni, peppers, green olives, black olives, tomatoes, garlic & on
0
|
|
| Garlic Knots (12) | $4.95 |
$0.50 each
0
|
| Garlic Knots with Jay's Marinara | $4.95 |
0
|
| Specialty Pizzas |
| Our signature pizzas mouse over a menu item for a description of our delicious ingredients |
| Breakfast Pizza | $17.99 |
Eggs with choice of bacon, ham or sausage, with mozzarella and cheddar
0
|
| White Pizza | $16.99 |
Parmesan, ricotta and mozzarella
0
|
| White Tomato Basil Pizza | $17.99 |
White pizza with tomato, mozzarella and basil
0
|
| Penne a la Vodka Pizza | $18.99 |
Penne pasta with jay's own vodka sauce and mozzarella
0
|
| Chicken Parm Pizza | $18.99 |
Breaded chicken cutlet with jay's marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese
0
|
| Lemon Chicken Pizza | $18.99 |
Chicken cutlet with sauteed mushrooms and light lemon sauce, topped with mozzarella
0
|
| Vegetable Mediterranean Pizza | $17.00 |
Spinach, grape tomatoes, kalamata olives, oil and garlic and feta cheese
0
|
| Chicken Bacon Ranch | $19.99 |
Breaded chicken, diced tomatoes, bacon, ranch dressing and mozzarella cheese
0
|
| Taco Pizza | $17.99 |
Beef, onions, peppers, jalapenos and cheddar
0
|
| Spinach Gorgonzola Pizza | $18.99 |
Sauteed spinach, fresh diced tomatoes, fresh garlic, gorgonzola and mozzarella cheese
0
|
| Cheese Steak Pizza | $18.99 |
Steak, peppers, onions, mozzarella and american cheese
0
|
| Salad Pizza | $17.99 |
House salad tossed with italian dressing and fresh mozzarella placed on a whole wheat pizza crust
0
|
| Veggie Breakfast Pizza | $17.99 |
Eggs with peppers, onions, tomatoes, mozzarella and cheddar
0
|
| White Broccoli Pizza | $17.99 |
Three cheeses and chopped broccoli
0
|
| Margherita | $17.99 |
Mozzarella, tomato, basil and garlic
0
|
| Baked Ziti Pizza | $18.99 |
Zita, ricotta, tomato sauce and mozzarella
0
|
| Chicken Marsala Pizza | $18.99 |
Breaded chicken cutlet with sauteed mushrooms, marsala sauce and mozzarella
0
|
| Buffalo Chicken | $18.99 |
Tender fried chicken cutlet tossed with buffalo sauce, bleu cheese available
0
|
| Honey BBQ Chicken Pizza | $18.99 |
Breaded crispy chicken tossed with honey barbecue sauce, topped with mozzarella cheese
0
|
| Meat Lovers Pizza | $21.99 |
Pepperoni, meatballs, sausage and bacon
0
|
| Ranchero Pizza | $17.99 |
Bacon, ranch, mozzarella, cheddar, pepperoni and tomato sauce
0
|
| Eggplant Parm Pizza | $17.99 |
Fried eggplant, ricotta, tomato sauce and mozzarella
0
|
| Leave it to us Everything Pizza | $18.99 |
It's everything but the kitchen sink
0
|
| Deli Sandwiches |
| Served on bread or a roll, heroes for $1.00 more. Pickles $0.25, cheese $0.75, tomatoes $0.25, bacon $1.00, avocado $1.00, hot sweet or roasted peppers $0.75, fresh mozzarella $1.00, lettuce & onion free |
| Tuna Salad on a Roll or Bread | $5.95 |
0
|
| Egg Salad on a Roll or Bread | $4.95 |
0
|
| Shrimp Salad on a Roll or Bread | $6.95 |
0
|
| Ham & Cheese on a Roll or Bread | $5.75 |
0
|
| Olive Loaf on a Roll or Bread | $4.50 |
0
|
| Cheese on a Roll or Bread | $4.50 |
0
|
| PB &J on a Roll or Bread | $2.95 |
0
|
| Salami on a Roll or Bread | $4.95 |
0
|
| Turkey on a Roll or Bread | $5.95 |
0
|
| Virginia Ham on a Roll or Bread | $5.95 |
0
|
| Tuna Salad Hero | $6.95 |
0
|
| Egg Salad Hero | $5.95 |
0
|
| Shrimp Salad Hero | $7.95 |
0
|
| Ham & Cheese Hero | $6.75 |
0
|
| Olive Loaf Hero | $5.50 |
0
|
| Cheese Hero | $5.50 |
0
|
| PB & J Hero | $3.95 |
0
|
| Salami Hero | $5.95 |
0
|
| Turkey Hero | $6.95 |
0
|
| Virginia Ham Hero | $6.95 |
0
|
| Chicken Salad on a Roll or Bread | $5.95 |
0
|
| Seafood Salad on a Roll or Bread | $5.95 |
0
|
| Ham on a Roll or Bread | $4.95 |
0
|
| Liverwurst on a Roll or Bread | $4.50 |
0
|
| Prosciutto on a Roll or Bread | $5.95 |
0
|
| Cappicola on a Roll or Bread | $4.95 |
0
|
| Bologna on a Roll or Bread | $4.50 |
0
|
| Spiced Ham on a Roll or Bread | $4.50 |
0
|
| Roast Beef on a Roll or Bread | $6.95 |
0
|
| Fresh Mozzarella on a Roll or Bread | $4.95 |
0
|
| Chicken Salad Hero | $6.95 |
0
|
| Seafood Salad Hero | $6.95 |
0
|
| Ham Hero | $5.95 |
0
|
| Liverwurst Hero | $5.50 |
0
|
| Prosciutto Hero | $6.95 |
0
|
| Cappicola Hero | $5.95 |
0
|
| Bologna Hero | $5.50 |
0
|
| Spiced Ham Hero | $5.50 |
0
|
| Roast Beef Hero | $7.95 |
0
|
| Fresh Mozzarella Hero | $5.95 |
0
|
| Hot Sandwiches |
| Any of these sandwiches can be topped with melted cheese for $0.75 |
| Meatballs on a Roll | $5.50 |
Homemade meatballs with sauce
0
|
| Eggplant on a Roll | $5.50 |
Hand breaded eggplant with sauce
0
|
| Pastrami on a Roll | $6.95 |
Thin sliced pastrami with brown spicy mustard
0
|
| Cheesesteak | $7.95 |
Sliced roasted beef with peppers, onions and mushrooms with melted american cheese
0
|
| Susage & Pepper Hero | $6.50 |
Sweet italian sausage with pepper and onions
0
|
| Chicken Cutlet Hero | $6.95 |
Hand breaded cutlet plain or with sauce
0
|
| Reuben Hero | $7.95 |
Corned beef or pastrami with sauerkraut and russian dressing, topped with swiss cheese
0
|
| Sausage & Peppers on a Roll | $5.50 |
Sweet italian sausage with peppers and onions
0
|
| Chicken cutlet on a Roll | $5.95 |
Hand breaded chicken plain or with sauce
0
|
| Reuben on a Roll | $6.95 |
Corned beef or pastrami with sauerkraut and russian dressing, topped with Swiss cheese
0
|
| Meatball Hero | $6.50 |
Homemade meatballs with sauce
0
|
| Eggplant Hero | $6.50 |
Hand breaded eggplant with sauce
0
|
| Pastrami Hero | $7.95 |
Thin sliced pastrami with brown spicy mustard
0
|
| Grilled Cheese | $4.95 |
With melted american cheese, choice of bread
0
|
| Specialty Sandwiches |
| Mouse over any menu item for a description of our delicious ingredients |
| Texas Ranger on a Roll | $6.95 |
Chicken cutlet, bacon, BBQ sauce & melted cheese
0
|
| Jay's American Combo on a Roll | $5.95 |
Turkey, ham, american and swiss
0
|
| Chicken Cordon Bleu on a Roll | $6.95 |
Fried chicken cutlet with ham, melted swiss cheese and honey mustard dressing
0
|
| Turkey Sombrero on a Roll | $5.95 |
Turkey breast smothered with melted cheddar and topped with chili
0
|
| Honey of a Sandwich on a Roll | $5.95 |
Honey turkey, honey ham, muenster cheese, lettuce and honey mustard dressing
0
|
| Cheese | $0.75 |
0
|
| Texas Ranger Hero | $7.95 |
Chicken cutlet, bacon, BBQ sauce & melted cheese
0
|
| Jay's American Combo Hero | $6.95 |
Turkey, ham, american and swiss
0
|
| Leo's Eggplant Tower Hero | $6.95 |
Fresh fried eggplant, topped with jay's zesty marinara sauce, roasted peppers, and smothered with melted mozzarella cheese
0
|
| Jay's Italian Combo Hero | $6.95 |
Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone
0
|
| Sir Wrap A Lot | $7.50 |
Grilled chicken, sauteed mushrooms and spinach topped with melted cheddar cheese, all wrapped or toasted on the panini grill
0
|
| Sundried Tomato Overdose | $7.50 |
Grilled chicken, feta cheese, spinach and sundried tomatoes with jay's special dressing in a sundried tomato wrap, served cold or warm
0
|
| Bleu Bayou on a Roll | $6.95 |
Turkey topped with bacon & melted cheese & then smothered in bleu cheese
0
|
| Mexican Cheese Steak on a Roll | $6.95 |
Roast beef with melted jalapeno cheese and salsa
0
|
| Leo's Eggplant Tower on a Roll | $5.95 |
Fresh fried eggplant, topped with jay's zesty marinara sauce, roasted peppers, and smothered with melted mozzarella cheese
0
|
| Jay's Italian Combo on a Roll | $5.95 |
Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone
0
|
| Lettuce and Onion |
0
|
|
| Friendly Service |
0
|
|
| Bleu Bayou Hero | $7.95 |
Turkey topped with bacon & melted cheese & then smothered in bleu cheese
0
|
| Mexican Cheese Steak Hero | $7.95 |
Roast beef with melted jalapeno cheese and salsa
0
|
| Turkey Sombrero Hero | $6.95 |
Turkey breast smothered with melted cheddar and topped with chili
0
|
| Honey of a Hero | $6.95 |
Honey turkey, honey ham, muenster cheese, lettuce and honey mustard dressing
0
|
| Italian Stallion | $7.95 |
Meatballs, eggplant, roasted peppers, tomato sauce, with melted cheese
0
|
| Cuban | $6.50 |
Ham, pork, swiss, pickkles, mustard & mayo on buttered bread pressed on the panini grill
0
|
| Hamburgers |
| Our 1/3 pound, hand-crafted burgers are sure to please, add fries for $1.50 |
| Hamburger | $3.95 |
Moist & juicy
0
|
| BBQ Bacon Burger | $5.95 |
With cheese
0
|
| Pepperoni Pizza Burger | $5.95 |
With sauce, cheese and pepperoni
0
|
| Italian Dog | $5.95 |
Two dogs with peppers, onions and potatoes in a hoagie roll
0
|
| Cheeseburger | $4.75 |
With melted american cheese
0
|
| Deluxe Burger | $5.95 |
Lettuce, tomato, onion and of course, french fries
0
|
| Hot Dog | $2.25 |
Boars head brand hot dog. Chili, onions and kraut available
0
|
* Disclaimer: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.
People Are Reading
-
13 Unmissable Thanksgiving Restaurant Deals in 2025Ready for a delicious & stress-free Thanksgiving 2025? Discover senior-friendly restaurant deals from Cracker Barrel, Perkins, and more, offering everything from classic turkey to exciting flavors! What will tempt you?
-
Top 12 Free Meals And Discounts For Veterans In 2025Celebrate Veterans Day 2025 with free meals and discounts from top restaurants like Applebee’s, Starbucks, and Outback Steakhouse—honoring service with gratitude and great food.
Hot Menus
- Applebee's Menu
- Arby's Menu
- Burger King Menu
- Chick-fil-A Menu
- Chipotle Mexican Grill Menu
- Cook Out Menu
- Domino's Pizza Menu
- Jersey Mike's Subs Menu
- KFC Menu
- McDonald's Menu
- Panera Bread Menu
- Papa Murphy's Menu
- Pizza Hut Menu
- Starbucks Coffee Menu
- Wendy's Menu
- Chili's Grill & Bar Menu
- Red Lobster Menu
- Texas Roadhouse Menu
- Bonefish Grill Menu
- Olive Garden Menu
Total Price