Milk And Sugar Cafe Prices in Bay Shore, NY 11706
Hours of Operation
-
Hours may fluctuate. For detailed hours of operation, please contact the store directly.
Restaurant Menu
| Appetizers |
| Cheese Board | $9.00 |
a selection of imported cheeses served with grapes, seven grain flatbreads and crackers
0
|
| Coconut Shrimp | $13.00 |
jumbo shrimp prepared with a mango and papaya salsa
0
|
| Three Cheese Fondue | $14.00 |
served with tempura vegetables, shrimp and multi grain breads
0
|
| Alaskan Crab Cakes | $12.00 |
crisp crab cakes served with a horseradish aioli
0
|
| Stuffed Portobella and Seafood | $11.00 |
portobella mushroom and seafood stuffing served with melted fresh mozzarella and a balsamic glaze
0
|
| Spinach Dip | $13.00 |
sauteed spinach in pernod cream sauce served with crisp tortillas
0
|
| Chicken Quesadillas | $11.00 |
with cheddar, cheese, onions, peppers, sour cream, guacamole and salsa
0
|
| Espresso BBQ Glazed Baby Back Ribs | $11.00 |
served with smashed apples and potato hash
0
|
| Salads |
| add grilled steak or tuna loin 7, add chicken $4.00, add shrimp $5.00. Large bowl serve 15-20, small bowl serves 10-15. |
| Oriental Salad | $9.00 |
shredded bok choy served with crisp wontons, tomato, black olives, and marinated chicken with a sesame vinaigrette
0
|
| Caesar Salad | $8.00 |
crisp baby romaine hearts served with garlic croutons, shaved reggiano parmesan
0
|
| Tomato and Mozzarella | $8.00 |
vine ripened tomato and fresh mozzarella served with an infused basil oil and a balsamic glaze
0
|
| Spinach and Roquefort Salad | $9.00 |
fresh spinach served with roquefort cheese and maple glazed walnuts with a champagne shallot vinaigrette
0
|
| Antipasto Salad | $9.00 |
organic wild greens with roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, prosciutto and artichoke hearts with an aged balsamic
0
|
| Sante Fe Taco Salad | $9.00 |
marinated grilled chicken served with black olives, tomato, shaved cheddar, sour cream and guacamole in a crisp chipotle shell
0
|
| Ahi Tuna Salad | $11.00 |
grilled ahi tuna served with fresh ginger, mango and papaya mojo with a soy orange vinaigrette over a shredded Asian slaw
0
|
| Port Pear salad | $9.00 |
port wine pears and walnut encrusted goat cheese over baby arugula with a raspberry vinaigrette
0
|
| Chopped salad | $9.00 |
corn, scallions, eggs, bacon and avocado with roasted vegetable vinaigrette
0
|
| House salad | $8.00 |
mixed greens topped with fresh vegetables and choice of dressing
0
|
| Spinach Salad | $40.00 - $65.00 |
maple glazed walnuts, gorgonzola cheese and a champagne vinaigrette
0
|
| Oriental Salad | $40.00 - $65.00 |
olives, tomato, marinated chicken, wontons and a sesame vinaigrette over bok-choy
0
|
| Antipasta Salad | $40.00 - $65.00 |
tomato, olives, artichokes, mozzarella and a balsamic vinaigretta over wild greens
0
|
| Sante Fe Salad | $40.00 - $65.00 |
shredded cheddar, tomato, olives, sour cream and guacamole
0
|
| Classic Caesar Salad | $40.00 - $65.00 |
crisp baby Romaine hearts served with garlic croutons shaved reggiano parmesan
0
|
| Tomato and Mozzarella | $40.00 - $65.00 |
vine ripened tomato and fresh mozzarella served with an infused basil oil and a balsamic glaze
0
|
| Port Pear Salad | $40.00 - $65.00 |
port wine pears and walnut encrusted goat cheese over baby arugula with a raspberry vinaigrette
0
|
| House Salad | $40.00 - $65.00 |
mixed greens, topped with fresh vegetables and choice of dressing
0
|
| Harvest Salad | $40.00 - $65.00 |
mixed greens, walnuts, cranberries gorgonzola cheese with a raspberry vinaigrette
0
|
| Sandwiches and Wraps |
| Smoked Salmon Sandwich | $11.00 |
served on pumpernickel with lettuce, tomato and chive cream cheese
0
|
| Turkey Club Sandwich | $8.00 - $8.75 |
fresh roasted turkey on a rustic roll with Swiss, lettuce tomato and mayonnaise
0
|
| Portobella Sandwich | $9.00 |
grilled portobella mushroom, zucchini squash and roasted peppers on focaccia bread, served with balsamic mayo
0
|
| Homemade Chicken Salad | $8.00 |
fresh shredded chicken with seasoning and zest on an onion roll
0
|
| 8oz Classic Angus Burger | $9.00 - $10.00 |
grilled to perfection angus burger served on a sesame bun with french fries, add bacon, mushrooms, fried onions or cheese - $0.75 each
0
|
| Crableg Sandwich | $10.00 |
fresh lump crabmeat with arugula, plum tomatoes and horseradish mustard on homemade firenza bread
0
|
| Open Faced Grilled Cheese | $7.00 |
with tomato, bacon and sauteed onion on classic challah bread
0
|
| Homemade Tuna Salad | $7.00 |
fresh tuna served in a pita with wild greens
0
|
| Panini Sandwich of the Day |
prepared fresh daily by the chef priced daily
0
|
|
| Bay Shore BLT | $8.00 |
bacon, lettuce and tomato with mayonnaise on classic white toast
0
|
| Milk and Sugar Garden Burger | $9.00 |
kidney beans, lentils and assorted vegetables served on a sesame bun served with French fries
0
|
| Blackened Sashimi Tuna Wrap | $12.00 |
with a teriyaki wasabi drizzle, shaved carrots and napa cabbage
0
|
| Grilled Chicken, Bacon and Avocada Wrap | $10.00 |
with cheddar cheese, scallions, tomato lettuce and a basil aloli
0
|
| Grilled Skirt Steak Wrap | $12.00 |
with a chipotle BBQ sauce, gorgonzola cheese, sauteed onions and roma tomato
0
|
| Desserts |
| something sweet |
| Cheesecake | $5.00 |
0
|
| Blueberry Pie | $4.00 |
0
|
| Warm Apple Tart | $7.00 |
0
|
| Refried Cheesecake | $6.00 |
0
|
| Chocolate Madness | $7.00 |
0
|
| Carrot Cake | $6.00 |
0
|
| Pecan Pie | $6.00 |
0
|
| Chocolate White Raspberry Mousse | $7.00 |
0
|
| Cannoli | $3.00 |
chocolate or plain
0
|
| Chocolate Fudge Brownie | $2.00 |
with or without nuts
0
|
| Jumbo Chocolate Chip Cookie | $2.00 |
0
|
| Vanilla Refried Ice Cream | $6.00 |
0
|
| Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie | $6.00 |
0
|
| Biscotti | $2.00 |
assorted flavors
0
|
| Caramel Apple Crumb | $7.00 |
0
|
| Daily Dessert Specials |
priced accordingly
0
|
|
| Homemade Ice Cream Sundaes | $8.00 |
0
|
| Hot Belgian Waffle |
with ice cream and whipped cream
0
|
|
| Brownie Sundae |
with whipped cream and your choice of ice cream
0
|
|
| Chocolate Chip Sundae |
with ice cream, fudge, caramel and whipped cream
0
|
|
| Banana Split |
with ice cream, hot fudge and whipped cream
0
|
|
| Gourmet Ice Cream | $3.00 - $4.00 |
vanilla, butterscotch praline chocolate cappuccino crunch cookie dough, chocolate chip flavor of the month
0
|
| Homemade Sorbet | $4.00 |
orange, lemon, raspberry
0
|
| Create Your Own Smores Fondue | $15.00 |
create your own smores with chocolate, marshmallows and graham crackers on an open flame (serves two)
0
|
| Create A Cappuccino |
| shot of espresso, steamed milk and whipped cream, iced decaf or frozen available, sugar free, caramel, vanilla, hazelnut |
| Hazelnut, Peanut Butter and Vanilla | $5.00 |
0
|
| Vanilla and Marshmallow | $5.00 |
0
|
| Coconut, Chocolate and Caramel | $5.00 |
0
|
| Hazelnut, Chocolate and Caramel | $5.00 |
0
|
| Raspberry and Vanilla | $5.00 |
0
|
| Cherry and Chocolate | $5.00 |
0
|
| Chocolate, Almond and Coconut | $5.00 |
0
|
| Banana, Marshmallow and Chocolate | $5.00 |
0
|
| Chocolate and Marshmallow | $5.00 |
0
|
| Irish Cream and Hazelnut | $5.00 |
0
|
| Chocolate, Hazelnut and Mini Marshmallows | $5.00 |
0
|
| Peanut Butter | $5.00 |
0
|
| Marshmallow and Banana | $5.00 |
0
|
| Chocolate, Peanut Butter and Caramel | $5.00 |
0
|
| Something Smooth |
| Orange Cream Crushes | $3.00 |
0
|
| Ice Cream Soda | $3.00 |
0
|
| Chocolate/ Vanilla Egg Creams | $4.00 |
0
|
| Smoothies | $4.00 |
0
|
| Coffees |
| decaf or iced available, whipped or soy milk $0.50 extra |
| Milk and Sugar's House Blend | $1.95 |
regular or decaf
0
|
| Flavored Coffee of the Day | $1.95 |
0
|
| Cafe au Lait | $2.25 - $2.50 |
coffee with steamed milk
0
|
| Cafe au Lait. | $1.50 - $1.75 |
with shot of syrup
0
|
| Steamers | $2.75 |
steamed milk with shot of flavored syrup and whip
0
|
| Hot Cocoa | $2.00 - $3.00 |
with whipped cream and marshmallow, with shot of syrup $0.50, with scoop of ice cream $1.00
0
|
| Espresso Shot | $2.50 - $2.00 |
0
|
| Espresso Macchiato | $2.00 |
espresso with chocolate and whipped cream
0
|
| Cappuccino | $3.00 |
0
|
| Cappuccino Fancy | $3.25 |
with whipped cream and cinnamon
0
|
| Double Cappuccino | $3.75 |
0
|
| Caramel Macchiato | $3.25 |
0
|
| Double Caramel Macchiato | $4.25 |
0
|
| Cafe Latte | $3.00 |
0
|
| Double Cafe Latte | $3.75 |
0
|
| Mochaccino | $3.25 |
0
|
| Double Mochaccino | $3.75 |
0
|
| Breve | $3.75 |
double shot espresso with steamed half and half
0
|
| Frozen cappuccino | $4.00 |
with caramel and chocolate
0
|
| Frozen Hot Chocolate | $4.00 |
with mini marshmallows
0
|
| Frozen Latte | $4.00 |
0
|
| Teas |
| Lipton Decaf or Regular | $2.00 |
0
|
| Lemon Herbal | $2.00 |
0
|
| Orange Pekoe | $2.00 |
0
|
| Darjeeling Peppermint | $2.00 |
0
|
| China Oolong | $2.00 |
0
|
| Chamomile Herbal | $2.00 |
0
|
| Green Herbal | $2.00 |
0
|
| Earl Grey | $2.00 |
0
|
| English Breakfast | $2.00 |
0
|
| Jasmine with Flowers | $2.00 |
0
|
| Gourmet Teas Wrapped in Silk |
| Rain Forest Mint | $2.95 |
0
|
| Tropical Green | $2.95 |
0
|
| Vanilla Bean | $2.95 |
0
|
| Ginger Twist | $2.95 |
0
|
| Specialty Loose Teas |
| Black Currant Tea | $3.00 |
0
|
| Earl Grey | $3.00 |
0
|
| English Breakfast | $3.00 |
0
|
| Peach Fruit | $3.00 |
0
|
| Cinnamon Spice | $3.00 |
0
|
| Flavored Tea Blends |
| Bayshore Blend | $4.00 |
Ceylon tea with a mysterious combo of grenadine and vanilla
0
|
| Fire Island Blend | $4.00 |
Ceylon tea with a delightful combo of cinnamon and cloves
0
|
| Main Street Blend | $4.00 |
Heavenly green tea with maple sweeteners and blackberry flavoring
0
|
| Chai Tea | $5.00 |
cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves and honey
0
|
* Disclaimer: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.
People Are Reading
-
13 Unmissable Thanksgiving Restaurant Deals in 2025Ready for a delicious & stress-free Thanksgiving 2025? Discover senior-friendly restaurant deals from Cracker Barrel, Perkins, and more, offering everything from classic turkey to exciting flavors! What will tempt you?
-
Top 12 Free Meals And Discounts For Veterans In 2025Celebrate Veterans Day 2025 with free meals and discounts from top restaurants like Applebee’s, Starbucks, and Outback Steakhouse—honoring service with gratitude and great food.
Hot Menus
- Applebee's Menu
- Arby's Menu
- Burger King Menu
- Chick-fil-A Menu
- Chipotle Mexican Grill Menu
- Cook Out Menu
- Domino's Pizza Menu
- Jersey Mike's Subs Menu
- KFC Menu
- McDonald's Menu
- Panera Bread Menu
- Papa Murphy's Menu
- Pizza Hut Menu
- Starbucks Coffee Menu
- Wendy's Menu
- Chili's Grill & Bar Menu
- Red Lobster Menu
- Texas Roadhouse Menu
- Bonefish Grill Menu
- Olive Garden Menu
Total Price