Mister Pizza Prices in Buffalo, NY 14226

4.0 based on 125 votes

Hours of Operation

  • Hours may fluctuate. For detailed hours of operation, please contact the store directly.

Restaurant Menu

Salads
Choice of italian, lo-cal italian, french, ranch, greek, honey mustard or bleu cheese dressing.
Chef Salad $5.65 - $7.10
0
Chef Salad with Chicken $6.45 - $7.90
0
Antipasto Salad $7.65 - $10.10
0
Tuna Salad (Albacore) $6.50 - $8.10
0
Tacos Salad $6.25
0
Taco Salad with Chicken or Steak $7.70
0
Caesar Salad (All Romaine) $6.25 - $7.30
Anchovies on request
0
Caesar Salad with Chicken $7.30 - $8.75
0
Greek Salad (All romaine) $5.75 - $6.25
0
Greek Salad with Chicken $6.60 - $7.85
0
Pasta Dishes
All dinners are prepared with our homemade sauce and served with a dinner salad, bread, and your choice of pasta (spaghetti, zitti, or fettucini).
Spaghetti Dinner $8.95 - $10.95
Add one meatball or sausage for $1.50
0
Ravioli Dinner $10.99
Raviolis served over our red sauce with melted mozzarella. Add one meatball or sausage for $1.50
0
Baked Ziti $10.99
Ziti over our red sauce baked in melted mozzarella. Add one meatball or sausage for $1.50
0
Fettucini Alfredo $11.99
Fettucini pasta served with our alfredo sauce. Add chicken for $2.95
0
Chicken Parmigiana $12.99
Our freshly breaded chicken breast served over our choice of pasta and our red sauce with melted mozzarella.
0
Eggplant Parmigiana $12.99
Our freshly breaded eggplant served over your choice of pasta and our red sauce with melted mozzarella.
0
Veal Parmigiana $13.99
Our freshly breaded veal served with your choice of pasta with our red sauce.
0
Pizza
10” Cheese & 1 Item Pizza $12.00
0
10” Specialty Pizza $14.00
0
12 Sqs. or 8 Slices with Cheese $13.40
0
15" Medum Pizza $14.95
With cheese & margherita pepperoni
0
16 Sqs. or 12 Slices with Cheese $14.70
0
17" Large Pizza $16.75
With cheese & margherita pepperoni
0
12 Sqs. with Cheese & One Ingredient $16.75
0
1/2 Sheet Pizza $3.55
Steak, chicken, chicken fingers, shrimp or stuffed peppers. Extra
0
24 Sqs. with Cheese & One Ingredient $26.60
0
Sheet Pizza $7.10
Steak, chicken, chicken fingers, shrimp or stuffed peppers. Extra
0
By The Slice $2.50
With cheese or cheese & pepperoni
0
Specialty Slices $3.00
Any specialty slice available
0
Topping Selection  
Additional ingredients: french onions, hot peppers, tomatoes, green or black olives, anchovies, double pepperoni, ground beef, bacon, fresh mushrooms, spinach, artichoke hearts, jalapeno peppers, swe
0
Specialty Pizza's
New York Style $15.15 - $31.10
Extra thin dough with our own style pizza sauce and mozzarella cheese. Added ingredients are extra.
0
Mister Steak $17.65 - $36.00
Fresh cut sirloin steak, baked on our famous dough with a blend of oil and spices, topped with sliced spanish onions, fresh sweet peppers, fresh mushrooms, american, swiss, and mozzarella cheeses. Ho
0
Mister Chicken Wing Pizza $17.20 - $35.20
Our special dressing, chicken (hot, medium or mild), celery & carrots with mozzarella, fontinella, romano & light cheddar cheese on top of our famous dough. Onions if desired. Bleu cheese served on t
0
Mister Chicken Finger $17.20 - $35.20
Tender chicken fingers (hot, medium or mild), whole tomatoes, romano cheese on top of our famous dough, with special dressing and mozzarella cheese. Bleu cheese served on the side. Also available wit
0
Mister Cheeseburger Pizza $15.40 - $34.00
Our all beef patties, yellow american, swiss, and cheddar cheeses, onions and our own special sauce. With bacon add $0.75 to medium, add $0.75 to large, add $2.10 to sheet
0
Mister Chicken Bacon Ranch $17.45 - $35.40
Begins with a ranch base with chicken and bacon, covered with mozzarella and cheddar cheese.
0
White Pizza $15.35 - $32.95
Whole tomatoes and crisp sliced onions mixed in with imported italian olive oil, freshly grated romano and fontinella cheeses, topped with mozzarella cheese. Anchovies on request.
0
Mister Veggie $16.25 - $35.60
Our delicious crust topped with our own syle pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese, fresh mushrooms, fresh sweet peppers, sliced onions and black and green olives. Hot peppers if desired
0
Deluxe Veggie $17.05 - $36.20
Our delicious crust topped with our own syle pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese, fresh mushrooms, fresh sweet peppers, sliced onions and black and green olives. also includes; broccoli, spinach, sliced t
0
Mister Veggie Delite $17.05 - $36.20
Our special dough with a white base, minced garlic, roasted red peppers, onions, sliced tomato, zucchini and artichokes with a blend of cheeses.
0
Chicken Alfredo Pizza $16.20 - $33.40
Specially seasoned chicken breast with broccoli, monterey jack and mozzarella cheese on top of our famous dough with alfredo sauce base. Substitute sliced tomatoes for broccoli at no extra charge.
0
Spinach & Ricotta Pizza $15.65 - $31.50
Fresh spinach, mushrooms and spanish onions sauteed over ricotta cheese, topped with mozzarella cheese. with or without our famous style pizza sauce. Margherita pepperoni or sausage if desired.
0
Sicilian Pizza $15.10 - $32.55
An old time favorite includes, our own special blend of whole tomatoes mixed in with imported italian olive oil, fresh grated romano cheese, crisp sliced onions, with your choice of fresh sweet or ta
0
Senor Taco $17.65 - $36.00
A blend of monterey jack and cheddar cheeses with our own style taco meat, topped with black olives, spanish onions and fresh tomatoes. Add lettuce at no extra charge. Hot peppers if desired.
0
Mister Eggplant $16.05 - $34.50
Fresh eggplant baked in our own style pizza sauce, covered with mozzarella cheese, and topped with freshly grated romano cheese.
0
Mister Meat Lovers $18.10 - $36.40
Margherita pepperoni sausage, bacon, ham, mozzarella cheese baked on our famous dough. Substitute ground beef or cappocola at no extra charge.
0
Italian Style Pizza $15.15 - $31.10
Our own style pizza sauce with freshly grated romano along with a blend of sliced spanish onions. Also try it with margherita pepperoni or fresh italian sausage at no additional chrage.
0
Broccoli Chicken $16.80 - $35.30
Our famous crust topped with specially seasoned chicken breast and broccoli with four cheeses - fontinella, cheddar, romano and mozzarella.
0
Breakfast Pizza $15.65 - $31.50
Fresh eggs, potatoes, sweet or hot peppers, ez onions, sausage, cheddar and monterey jack cheeses, on top of our famous pizza dough. Substitute ham or bacon at no extra charge.
0
Mister Greek $15.15 - $30.75
Olive oil, our special seasoning, sliced tomatoes, crisp sliced spanish onions, a combination of mozzarella and feta cheese, topped with greek olives. With chicken or steak add $1.60 to medium add $1
0
Barbeque Chicken $16.45 - $34.20
Chicken breast in our own special BBQ sauce, then topped with mozzarella and cheddar cheeses and bacon. Onions if desired.
0
Mister Potato Pizza $16.50 - $33.80
Potatoes, bacon, chives and three cheeses. Sour cream served on the side
0
Parmigiana Pizza $16.50 - $34.80
Our own style pizza sauce with romano cheese, onions, fresh mushrooms, tender pieces of chicken breasts, topped with mozzarella cheese. Substitute sausage or eggplant at no extra cost
0
Mister Hot Pepper $17.85 - $36.20
Stuffed hot peppers (meatless), roasted peppers, mozzarella cheese baked in our own famous style pizza sauce. Mushrooms if desired.
0
Mister Hawaiian $15.65 - $33.20
A refreshing combination of juicy pineapple chunks, strips of ham, topped with almond slices and maraschino cherries on top of our own famous style pizza sauce and mozzarella cheese.
0
Chicken in the Grass $17.90 - $35.20
Specially seasoned chicken breast, smothered in fresh spinach, then topped with four imported cheeses. Substitute steak or shrimp at no extra cost.
0
Broccoli, Ricotta & Cheddar Pizza $16.45 - $34.00
Our delicious crust topped with ricotta cheese, fresh broccoli, sliced onions and cheddar cheese.
0
The Works $17.50 - $38.30
Treat yourself to a full course meal of a pizza that includes, mozzarella cheese, margherita pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, with a mixture of black and green olives hot and sweet peppers, sliced onions
0
The Popeye Pizza $15.45 - $31.20
Fresh spinach, mushrooms and spanish onions sauteed in garlic on top of our famous dough, with special dressing and mozzarella cheese.
0
Mister Shrimp Scampi $16.80 - $35.10
A mixture of oil, spices and a blend of four cheeses, topped with crisp sliced spanish onions, sweet peppers, jumbo tiger shrimp and bacon.
0
Mister Four-in-One $17.80 - $38.40
Four pizza's in one with 1/4 sausage, 1/4 chicken, 1/4 shrimp, 1/4 steak, baked on our famous dough with oil and spices, sliced spanish onions, fresh sweet peppers and mushrooms, american, swiss and
0
Chicken Wings
Other styles of chicken wings
Italian  
0
Garlic  
0
Honey Mustard  
0
Cajun  
0
Honey BBQ  
0
Teriyaki  
0
Hot BBQ  
0
Suicidal  
0
Regular Wings
Mild, medium, hot, or suicidal. Extra celery, blue cheese, BBQ or hot sauce $0.75
Single (10) Wings $8.45
With (1) bleu cheese, celery & carrots
0
Double (20) Wings $14.05
With (1) bleu cheese, celery & carrots
0
Triple (30) Wings $20.10
With (2) bleu cheese, celery & carrots
0
Bucket (50) Wings $31.20
With (3) bleu cheese, celery & carrots
0
Barbeque Wings
Italian, honey mustard, honey BBQ, hot BBQ, garlic, cajun, teriyaki wings. Extra celery, blue cheese, BBQ or hot sauce $0.80
Single (10) Wings $9.45
With (1) bleu cheese, celery & carrots
0
Double (20) Wings $15.95
With (1) bleu cheese, celery & carrots
0
Triple (30) Wings $22.15
With (2) bleu cheese, celery & carrots
0
Bucket (50) Wings $34.40
With (3) bleu cheese, celery & carrots
0
Boneless Wings
Single (10) Boneless Wings $8.85
With (1) bleu cheese, celery & carrots
0
Double (20) Boneless Wings $14.05
With (1) bleu cheese, celery & carrots
0
Triple (30) Boneless Wings $19.95
With (2) bleu cheese, celery & carrots
0
Bucket (50) Boneless Wings $29.80
With (3) bleu cheese, celery & carrots
0
Cold Subs
All subs are served on a white or wheat fresh seedless roll with cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and your choice of oil, mayo or miracle whip. Onions on request only. All rolls are toasted. Whole 12", mini 8"
Cheese $5.10 - $4.25
0
Veggie Delight $7.20 - $5.90
Cheese, lettuce, tomato, mushrooms, green & black olives. Onions, sweet peppers or hot peppers on request
0
Ham $6.90 - $5.95
0
Salami $6.70 - $5.55
0
Tuna $7.30 - $6.20
All white albacore tuna meat
0
Chicken Salad $8.05 - $6.95
0
Turkey $6.90 - $5.95
0
Turkey Club $7.50 - $6.15
0
Ham & Turkey $6.90 - $5.95
0
Ham, Turkey, Bacon $7.75 - $6.40
0
Assorted $6.90 - $5.75
Ham, salami, cappocola
0
Roast Beef $8.30 - $7.05
U.s.d.a. choice top round, try it on kimmelweck sub roll.
0
Cappocola $6.90 - $5.95
0
Bologna $5.45 - $4.45
With lettuce & tomato
0
Hot Subs
All subs are served on a white or wheat fresh seedless roll with cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and your choice of oil, mayo or miracle whip. Mozzarella cheese, provolone cheese, swiss cheese, double cheese, fried mushrooms, hot peppers, sweet peppers, jalapen
Chicken Breast Fillet $8.20 - $7.10
0
Chicken Club $8.85 - $7.70
With breast fillet & bacon
0
Chicken Bacon Ranch $8.55 - $7.30
With lettuce, tomato, swiss cheese and ranch dressing onions on request
0
BBQ Chicken $8.45 - $7.20
Lettuce & tomato on request
0
Chicken Parmesan $8.35 - $7.20
Baked with mozzarella cheese
0
Chicken Finger $8.60 - $7.25
Mild, medium, or hot with bleu cheese
0
Chicken Cordon Bleu $8.55 - $7.30
Breast fillet, ham and american cheese
0
Chicken & Spinach $9.10 - $7.75
On garlic bread with mozzarella cheese lettuce, tomato & onions on request.
0
Chicken & Dandelions $9.30 - $7.95
On garlic bread with mozzarella cheese lettuce, tomato & onions on request.
0
Chicken or Steak Soulvaki $8.50 - $7.10
With lettuce, tomato, green peppers, onions, or special greek dressing & feta cheese
0
Steak & Cheese $8.85 - $7.70
0
Steak & Chicken Finger $9.75 - $8.10
0
Steak and Spinach $9.10 - $7.75
On garlic bread with mozzarella cheese (lettuce, tomato, & onions on request)
0
Steak & Dandelions $9.30 - $7.95
On garlic bread with mozzarella cheese (lettuce, tomato & onion on request)
0
Steak & Sausage $9.30 - $8.10
Lettuce, tomato & onions on request
0
Sausage $7.55 - $6.40
0
Sausage & Spinach $8.30 - $7.00
On garlic bread with mozzarella cheese (lettuce, tomato & onions on request.)
0
Sausage & Dandelions $8.75 - $7.50
On garlic bread with mozzarella cheese (lettuce, tomato & onions on request.)
0
Sausage Parmesan $8.60 - $7.45
Baked with mozzarella cheese
0
Eggplant Parmesan $7.20 - $6.00
Baked with mozzarella cheese
0
Veal Parmesan $8.55 - $7.30
Made from real veal and baked with mozzarella cheese
0
Veal Sub $8.55 - $7.30
Made from real Veal
0
Ham & Cheese $6.90 - $5.75
Lettuce & tomato on request
0
Fried Bologna & Onions $6.70 - $5.55
Lettuce, tomato & onions on request
0
B.L.T. $6.90 - $5.95
Bacon, lettuce & tomato
0
Pizza Sub $6.05 - $4.95
With mozzarella cheese & pepperoni
0
Meatball Sub $7.70 - $6.60
With mozzarella cheese
0
The Sicilian $7.60 - $6.25
With tomato, onions, mozzarella & fontinella cheese - pepperoni or sausage
0
Hamburger $7.15 - $6.40
0
Cheeseburger $7.75 - $6.55
0
Bacon Cheeseburger $8.05 - $6.75
0
Cheeseburger Royal $8.55 - $7.20
With ham and two cheese
0
Royal $7.50 - $6.05
With cappocola, salami and sausage
0
Royal Deluxe $8.25 - $6.80
All subs are served on a white or wheat fresh seedless roll with cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and your choice of oil, mayo or miracle whip. Onions on request only. All rolls are toasted. With sausage, s
0
Fish Sub $7.55
11 oz. haddock filet, lettuce, tomato, tartar sauce, choice of yellow american or swiss cheese
0
Stuffed Hot Pepper Sub $8.45 - $7.20
With provolone & romano cheese, caesar dressing (baked in oven).
0
Roast Beef $8.75 - $7.50
Usda choice top round baked with mozzarella, try it on kimmelweck sub roll. lettuce, tomato and onions on request
0
Roast Beef Classic $8.95 - $7.70
Usda choice top round, baked on garlic bread with mozzarella cheese and mushrooms, try it on kimmelweck sub roll. Lettuce, tomato & onions on request
0
BBQ Rib Bomber $7.10
Lettuce & tomato on request
0
Pepper & Egg Bomber $5.55
Hot or sweet peppers, cheese on request
0
Hoagies
Steak Hoagie $8.30
1/4 lb. of ribeye, served with fried onions, melted cheese, lettuce, tomato and our special hoagie sauce. Substitute with our own BBQ sauce at no extra charge.
0
Turkey Hoagie $8.30
1/4 lb. of turkey, served with fried onions, melted cheese, lettuce, tomato and our special sauce.
0
Chicken Hoagie $8.30
1/4 lb. breast fillet, served with fried onions, melted cheese, lettuce, tomato and our special hoagie sauce. Substitute with our own BBQ sauce at no extra cost.
0
Philly Steak Hoagie $8.60
1/4 lb. of ribeye, served with fried onions, melted cheez whiz, with sweet or hot peppers. Add mushrooms at no extra charge.
0
Philly Turkey Hoagie $8.60
W1/4 lb. of turkey, served with fried onions, melted cheez whiz, with sweet or hot peppers. Add mushrooms at no extra charge.
0
Tacos
All tacos are served on a soft shell with cheese, lettuce, tomao and your choice of sauce. Mild, medium, hot or suicidal. Onions on request. Extras; double cheese small $0.45, large $0.55, double meat small $0.60, large $0.95, sour cream small $0.45, larg
Meat $2.20 - $3.40
0
Cheese $2.10 - $3.20
0
Tuna (Albacore) $2.70 - $3.65
0
Steak Taco $3.40 - $4.55
0
Chicken Taco $3.40 - $4.55
0
Wraps
Served with cheese, lettuce, & tomato. Onions on request.
Turkey $6.65
0
Tuna $7.45
0
Chicken Salad $7.90
0
Chicken Breast $8.05
0
Turkey Bacn Ranch $7.60
0
Chicken Fingers
Serve our fingers mild, medium, hot, or for the daring - suicidal. barbecue also available. Served with steak cut fries, bleu cheese, celery and carrots.
Single (5) Fingers $11.15
With (1) bleu cheese, celery & carrots
0
Single (10) Fingers $16.05
With (2) bleu cheese, celery & carrots
0
Bucket (50) Fingers $60.05
With (4) bleu cheese, celery & carrots
0
Dinners
Beer Battered Fish Dinner $9.95
11 oz. haddock, fries, coleslaw, lemon wedge with tartar sauce and a dinner roll
0
4 Piece Honey-Dipped Chicken Dinner $8.55
With fries, coleslaw and a dinner roll
0
Shrimp in a Basket Dinner $7.55
With fries, coleslaw, cocktail sauce and a dinner roll
0
Rib Dinner (Full Rack) $21.95
St. louie ribs served with steak fries, black olives, pepperoncini and roll
0
Rib Dinner (Half Rack) $12.45
St. louie ribs served with steak fries, black olives, pepperoncini and roll
0
Veal Dinner $9.95
0
Poppers
Jalapeno & Cheddar (6) $6.45
With bleu cheese dressing
0
Artichoke & Spinach $6.45
Choice of blu cheese or ranch dressing
0
Broccoli & Cheddar $6.45
With ranch dressing
0
Calzones
Calzone extras: italian sausage, pepperoni, ham, meatballs, onions, mushrooms, jalapeno peppers, hot peppers, sweet peppers, spinach, eggplant or artichoke hearts. Chicken or steak $1.90, stuffed hot peppers $2.75
Calzone (Serves 2) $9.45
Made with sauce, mozzarella and ricotta cheese then baked in our special dough shell.
0
Sides & Extras
Steak Cut Fries $2.75
0
Tator Tors $2.75
0
Loaded Fries $5.25
Cheddar, bacon, chives and side of sour cream
0
Deluxe Loaded Fries $5.75
Cheddar, salsa, taco meat and side of sour cream
0
Onion Rings $2.75
0
Seasoned Potato Wedges $2.75
0
Garlic Bread $2.20
0
Garlic Bread with Mozzarella Cheese $2.85
0
Garlic Bread with Mozzarella & Anchovies $3.35
0
Spinach Bread $3.95
Garlic & mozzarella
0
Bread Sticks (5) $4.95
Plain or garlic with side of pizza sauce
0
Mozzarella Sticks (6) $6.45
0
Stuffed Hot Peppers $10.95
0
Beef Pastelillos $2.45
0
Chicken Nuggets (Single) $4.95
Any way you like them with bleu cheese, celery, carrots and sauce on the side
0
Chicken Nuggets (Double) $6.95
Any way you like them with bleu cheese, celery, carrots and sauce on the side
0
Fried Mushrooms $6.45
With choice of bleu cheese or ranch dressing
0
Fried Cauliflower $6.45
With choice of bleu cheese or ranch dressing
0
Potato Skins (5) $6.45
With cheddar, bacon & sour cream
0
Veggie Potato Skins (5) $6.75
With cheddar, broccoli & sour cream
0
Pizza Logs $6.45
0
Fried Dough $3.95
With sugar and cinnamon. Add honey for $0.45
0
Desserts
Mister Apple or Cherry Dessert $9.00
Our famous dough on a 15” tray with apples or cherries, baked to perfection and topped with cinnamon and frosting
0
Cookies $0.75
0

* Disclaimer: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

Hot Menus

Total Price