Menu With Price Menu Petaluma Pie Company Menu

Petaluma Pie Company Menu and Prices

4.0 based on 173 votes

Choose My State

Salad

Garden Salad - Side	0	$3.00	Locally and sustainably grown salad greens tossed with balsamic vinaigrette and seasonal fruits or veggies. MORE
Garden Salad - Plate	0	$6.00	Locally and sustainably grown salad greens tossed with balsamic vinaigrette and seasonal fruits or veggies. MORE

Savory Hand Pies

Hand pies are great to eat on the go and can also be a great sit down meal with a salad and dessert. Usually available as take n bake or ready to eat.

Bacon and Egg Pie	0	$4.95	This breakfast pie can be eaten all day long. Filled with eggs from coastal hill farm with fresh green onions and spring hill organic cheddar combined with crispy maple bacon from prather ranch. MORE
Cheeseburger Pie	0	$4.95	Seasoned grass fed ground beef with melty spring hill dairy's aged organic cheddar. MORE
Chilean Beef Emapanada	0	$4.95	Traditional chilean beef empanada is sweet, savory, spicy and aromatic, all at once. Filling includes grass fed ground beef, hard boiled eggs, raisins, cilantro, onion, garlic, olives and a touch of MORE
Corn-ish Pasty	0	$4.95	Originally food for miners in cornwall, england, cornish pasties are name protected, so we call ours cornish. Like a beef stew in a hand held pie, our pasties feature chunks of grass feed beef, organ MORE
Curried Cauliflower and Chickpea	0	$4.95	Fresh cauliflower sautéed with onions, garlic, turmeric, coriander, garam masala tomatoes and chickpeas. MORE
Filipino Chicken Empanada	0	$4.95	This slightly spicy pie is based on a recipe sent by our friend alma who lives in the philippines. The hand pie is filled with mary's organic chicken, organic carrots, potatoes, peas, raisins, onions MORE
Jamaican Beef Patty	0	$4.95	A wholesome version of the classic jamaican beef patty that we remember from new york city. Grass fed ground beef seasoned with curry and thyme, enveloped in our delicious crust brushed with turmeric MORE
Mushroom and Goat Gouda	0	$4.95	Crimini and oyster mushrooms from solano mushroom farm cooked in wine, seasoned with thyme and tarragon in a delicious sauce with central coast creamery's goat gouda, one of our favorite cheeses. MORE

Spinach and Feta	0	$4.95	This middle east inspired pie is packed with organic spinach and organic cow milk feta cheese is seasoned with lemon juice and sumac. MORE

Savory Pot Pies

Feed yourself or your whole family. Usually available as take n bake as well as ready to eat.

Organic Chicken Pot Pie	$9.50 - $25.00	This favorite comfort food features Mary's organic chicken with celery, carrots and peas cooked in our home made chicken stock with tarragon thyme and gravy. MORE
Grass Fed Steak and Mushroom Pot Pie	$9.50 - $25.00	This hearty and satisfying pot pie is filled with grass fed beef slow cooked in a stew with our home made bone broth, wine, mushrooms, carrots and potatoes. MORE
Broccoli and Cheese and Peas Pot Pie	$9.50 - $25.00	Like mac and cheese but with veggies and in a pie. Made with organic or sustainably grown broccoli, onions and peas in a creamy cheddar sauce. MORE

Sides

Organic Side Salad

$3.00

Chilled Sweet Pies

Our cream pies are made with organic straus milk and cream and eggs from coastal hill farm in petaluma. most of these are available year round.

Banana Cream	0	$5.00 - $22.00	Layers of vanilla pastry cream and slices of organic bananas crowned with organic whipped cream and dark chocolate shavings. MORE
Butterscotch Cream Pie	0	$5.00 - $22.00	Sumptuous bourbon flavored butterscotch cream with a dab of whipped cream and a sprinkle of chocolate shavings. MORE
Coconut Cream Pie	0	$5.00 - $22.00	Coconut cream pie coconut milk based custard crowned with straus organic whipped cream and toasted coconut shavings. MORE
Elvis Pie	0	$5.00 - $22.00	A pie fit for the king. Layers of peanut butter cream, slices of fresh organic bananas, and chocolate cream, topped with fresh organic whipped cream and chopped peanuts. MORE
Lemon Meringue	0	$5.00 - $22.00	Lip smacking tart lemon curd topped with a twirl of meringue peak that melts in your mouth. MORE

Lime Pie	0	$5.00 - $22.00	Creamy and refreshing pie topped with whipped cream and a wedge of lime. we use persian limes instead of key limes. MORE
Mocha Cream	0	$5.00 - $22.00	Creamy mocha filling is made with straus milk, organic cocoa and thanksgiving's organic nicaraguan coffee. Warning: this pie is caffeinated. MORE
Organic Peanut Butter Cream Pie	0	$5.00 - $22.00	This decadent cream pie filling is made with cowgirl creamery's fromage blanc, organic peanut butter and organic whipped cream, sprinkled with chopped salted peanuts and drizzled with tcho chocolate. MORE
Strawberry Cream Pie	0	$5.00 - $22.00	Fresh organic strawberries sliced in a bed of vanilla pastry cream and topped with organic whipped cream and a slice of strawberry. MORE
Tcho Chocolate Cream	0	$5.00 - $22.00	Luscious chocolate cream filling made with tcho artisanal chocolate from san francisco. MORE

Year Round Sweet Pies

Pennsylvania Dutch Shoofly Pie	0	$5.00 - $20.00	This pennsylvania dutch inspired sweet molasses and organic brown sugar pie is covered with toothsome crumble top. MORE
German Chocolate Coconut	0	$5.00 - $22.00	As close to cake as we will get. This moist and chocolatey pie is made with tcho organic chocolate and organic coconut. So rich you might need to share. MORE

Seasonal Sweet Pies

Celebrate all of the seasons through pie. this part of our menu changes the most.

Classic Apple	0	$5.00 - $22.00	Celebrate local apple harvest. This old fashioned apple pie has a touch of true cinnamon and brown sugar in a buttery flaky crust. Made with pesticide free or organic fruit. MORE
Sour Cream Apple Pie	0	$5.00 - $22.00	Straus organic sour cream and chunks of tart apples baked with a crunchy sweet crumble top. Made with pesticide free or organic fruit. MORE
Blackberry Pie	0	$6.00 - $25.00	Blackberries, big and juicy, sweet and tart. Organic or very local and unsprayed. Best to call ahead for this one. MORE

Pear Ginger and Cardamom	0	$5.00 - $22.00	Festive pears are in season now. Asian pear, bosc or bartlett spiced with a touch of cardamom, fresh grated ginger and crystalized ginger and brown sugar in a buttery flaky crust. MORE
Shaker Meyer Lemon	0	$22.00	Thinly sliced local and sustainably grown meyer lemons macerated, peel and all, in unrefined organic sugar and baked with farm fresh egg custard. A wholesome take on traditional shaker pie. MORE
Organic Shaker Orange and Cranberry	0	$22.00	Thinly sliced oranges and cranberries are macerated in unrefined organic sugar and baked with farm fresh egg custard. A wholesome take on traditional shaker pie. MORE
Organic Pecan Pie	0	$6.00 - $25.00	If you always thought pecan pies are too cloying sweet, we may have the pie for you. No karo corn syrup here, we use light molasses and organic brown sugar and vanilla and, of course, organic pecans. MORE
Old Fashioned Pumpkin Pie	0	$5.00 - $20.00	Organic pumpkin sweetened with sorghum molasses and brown sugar for an old fashioned flavor. MORE
Sweet Potato Pie	0	$5.00 - $20.00	Our southern inspired sweet potato pie is not too sweet and spiced with cinnamon, vanilla and a touch of nutmeg. MORE
Triple Berry	0	$5.00 - $22.00	For the taste of summer, nothing beats triple berry pie. Usually we make it with organic raspberries, blueberries and strawberries, but sometimes it will have four or five berries. MORE

Organic Chocolate Chip Cookie	0	$1.50	Oversized chocolate chip cookie baked fresh daily at petaluma pie company. MORE
Hamantaschen	0	$1.50	This delicious jewish traditional cookie is made with buttery crust folded in a triangle enclosing a prune, peach, or lemon filling. Flavors: peach, prune, lemon MORE
Coconut Macaroons	0	$2.00	Organic coconut macaroons. Order with or without chocolate chips. Gluten free MORE

Ice Cream

Vanilla Ice Cream - Scoop	0	$3.00	Most pies go great with Straus organic vanilla ice cream. MORE
Vanilla Ice Cream - Pint	0	$5.00	Most pies go great with Straus organic vanilla ice cream. MORE

Beverages

Can of Soda	0	$1.50	Flavors: san pellegrino orange, san pellegrino blood orange, san pellegrino lemon, san pellegrino grapefruit, blue sky seltzer MORE
Bottle of Soda	0	$2.50	Flavors: mexican coke, virgil's root beer, virgil's black cherry cream, virgil's vanilla cream MORE
Nana Mae's Organic Apple Juice	0	$3.00	Get yourself a healthy and tasty bottle of this local organic juice. MORE
Numi Tea	0	$1.80	Choose from our selection of organic fair trade numi tea. MORE
Organic Cold Brewed Iced Coffee - 12 oz	0	$2.50	This is more than just cold coffee, it is cold brewed coffee. This process is done overnight and reduces the acidity and bitterness, leaving a big coffee flavor and caffeine. Come and taste the diffe MORE
Organic Cold Brewed Iced Coffee - 16 oz	0	$3.00	This is more than just cold coffee, it is cold brewed coffee. This process is done overnight and reduces the acidity and bitterness, leaving a big coffee flavor and caffeine. Come and taste the diffe MORE
Organic Iced Tea - 12 oz	0	$2.00	Choose between our teas of the day. We usually have a choice of mint, mate and earl grey. MORE
Organic Iced Tea - 16 oz	0	$2.50	Choose between our teas of the day. We usually have a choice of mint, mate and earl grey. MORE

Organic Fair Trade Coffee	0	$2.50	Our coffee is a medium roast nicaraguan from thanksgiving coffee. MORE
Straus Organic Milk	0	$2.50	Enjoy a refreshing glass of straus organic milk with your pie MORE
Strawberry Rhubarb Lemonade - 12 oz	0	$2.50	Made by us for you. Just like it sounds. Delicious and refreshing. MORE
Strawberry Rhubarb Lemonade - 16 oz	0	$3.00	Made by us for you. Just like it sounds. Delicious and refreshing. MORE
Tcho Hot Chocolate	0	$3.00	Straus organic milk and tcho chocolate make the best not too sweet hot chocolate. MORE

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.