Pizzeria New York Prices in Pickerington, OH 43147
Hours of Operation
- Mon: 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm
- Tue: 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm
- Wed: 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm
- Thu: 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm
- Fri: 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm
- Sat: 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm
- Sun: 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm
Restaurant Menu
| Appetizers |
| Breadsticks (4) | $3.49 |
Served with our homemade marinara sauce
0
|
| Cheezy Breadsticks | $4.99 |
8 Breadsticks smothered in mozzaralla cheese served with garlic butter or marinara sauce
0
|
| Mozzarella Sticks (6) | $5.99 |
Served with our homemade marinara sauce
0
|
| Loaded Fries Basket | $5.99 |
Smothered with cheddar cheese and bacon. Add jalapeno peppers for $0.75
0
|
| French Fries Basket | $2.99 |
0
|
| Pinwheels (4) | $7.99 |
Choose plain, cheese or pepperoni
0
|
| Baked Meatballs (3) | $4.99 |
Homemade meatballs smothered with mozzerella and marinara sauce
0
|
| Pepperoni Rolls | $2.99 - $3.99 |
Pepperorni stuffed in a cresent shaped dough served with our homemade basil marinara sauce
0
|
| Garlic Bread | $2.99 |
Add chesse for $0.50
0
|
| Garlic Knots (5) | $3.49 |
0
|
| Onion Rings | $4.99 |
0
|
| Zucchini Sticks Basket | $6.99 |
Served with our homemade marinara sauce
0
|
| Salads |
| Salad dressings: italian, ranch, low fat italian, vinaigrette, thousand island, bleu cheese, french, sweet & sour. Extra dressing add $0.50 |
| Tossed Salad | $3.99 - $6.99 |
Iceberg lettuce, sliced red onion & tomatoes with shredded provolone & croutons. Substitute romaine lettuce $1.00 add grilled chicken $1.99, add steak $2.49
0
|
| Caesar Salad | $3.99 - $6.99 |
Crisp romaine lettuce, croutons, imported romano cheese & caesar dressing. Add grilled chicken $1.99
0
|
| Fried Chicken Salad | $6.99 |
Served with chicken tenders plain or tossed with our wing sauce on a bed of mixed lettuce, topped with red onions, cheddar cheese, tomatoes
0
|
| Greek Salad | $4.99 |
Mixed lettuce with feta and romano cheeses, red onions, banana peppers, black olives
0
|
| Entrees |
| All entrees include a garlic knot or bread and dinner salad. Add alfredo sauce 1.99, add grilled chicken $2.99 |
| Spaghetti and Meatballs | $8.99 |
Served with our homemade marinara sauce
0
|
| Eggplant Parmigiano | $9.99 |
Baked breaded eggplant made with our homemade marinara sauce and served over a bed of spaghetti smothered in mozzarella cheese
0
|
| Cheese Ravioli | $8.99 |
Served with our homemade marinara sauce
0
|
| Stuffed Shells | $9.99 |
Pasta filled with ricotta cheese, smothered in our homemade marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese
0
|
| Tortellini | $8.99 |
Served with our homemade marinara sauce
0
|
| Fettuccine Alfredo | $11.99 |
Served with our homemade alfredo sauce
0
|
| Pizza |
| All dough is made fresh on the premises daily. Additional regular toppings each 12" $1.25, 14" $1.50, 16" $1.75, Extra cheese 12" $1.50, 14" $1.75, 16" $2.00. Regular toppings: bacon, banana peppers, black olives, green olive |
| One Topping | $10.99 - $14.99 |
0
|
| Pizza by the Slice |
| The Big Slice | $3.49 |
Specialty slice up to 3 regular toppings $4.49. Sicilian slice $2.95, add regular toppings $0.50 each
0
|
| Wings and Tenders |
| Additional dressing $0.50 each add celery $0.50 |
| Chicken Wings (10) | $7.99 |
Choose mild, hot, barbecue, teriyaki, cajun, caribbean jerk or blackened bourbon sauce. Served with ranch or bleu cheese dressing
0
|
| Boneless Wings | $8.99 |
0
|
| Chicken Tenders | $6.99 |
5 Chicken breast tenders served with dipping sauce. Add a basket of fries for $0.99
0
|
| Calzones, Strombolis & Pinwheels |
| Made fresh to order with our homemade marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese. Additional toppings extra |
| Calzone | $9.99 |
A moon-like shaped dough baked to a flaky crust, stuffed with up to 3 regular pizza toppings & our homemade marinara sauce on side
0
|
| Stromboli | $6.99 - $9.99 |
A roll-like shaped dough baked to a flaky crust, stuffed with up to 3 regular pizza toppings & our homemade marinara sauce on side
0
|
| Pinwheels | $7.49 |
Flaky bite-size crescents with your choice of cheese or pepperoni
0
|
| Oven Baked Subs |
| Cajun Bourbon Chicken Sub | $6.25 - $8.99 |
Fried chicken tenders smothered in bourbon sauce and mozzarella
0
|
| BBQ Chicken Sub | $6.25 - $8.99 |
Fried chicken tenders smothered in mozzeralla with BBQ sauce
0
|
| Veggie Sub | $5.99 - $8.49 |
Grilled onions, mushrooms, green peppers, tomatoes, provolone cheese
0
|
| Italian Sub | $6.25 - $8.99 |
Capicolla ham, Genoa salami, pepperoni, onions, banana peppers
0
|
| Eggplant Parmigiano | $6.25 - $8.99 |
Seasoned eggplant, marinara sauce, mozzarella cheese
0
|
| Meatball Parmigiano | $6.25 - $8.99 |
Hand rolled meatballs, marinara sauce, mozzarella cheese
0
|
| Italian Sausage Sub | $6.25 |
Sausage, sauteed onions & green peppers. Marinara sauce on request
0
|
| Philly Cheese Steak | $6.25 |
Sirloin tip steak, sauteed onions & green peppers, provolone cheese. Mayonnaise on request
0
|
| Grilled Chicken Sub | $6.25 |
Grilled chicken, provolone cheese with sauteed onions & green peppers. Marinara sauce on request
0
|
| Specialty Pizzas |
| Add regular toppings $2.00 each specialty toppings extra |
| Veggie Primavera | $16.99 - $18.99 |
Onions, green peppers, mushrooms & sliced tomatoes
0
|
| Eggplant Parm Pizza | $16.99 - $18.99 |
Eggplant smothered with mozzarella cheese & sauce
0
|
| Taco Pizza | $16.99 - $18.99 |
Seasoned beef, crumbled tortilla chips, cheddar, lettuce & tomato with sour cream & jalapeño on the side
0
|
| Paps Special | $16.99 - $18.99 |
Sausage, pepperoni, onions, mushrooms, green peppers & banana peppers
0
|
| New York White | $16.99 - $18.99 |
Ricotta, garlic, sliced tomatoes & mozzarella
0
|
| Chicken Alfredo Pizza | $16.99 - $18.99 |
Seasoned chicken, mozzarella & green peppers
0
|
| Meatball Pizza | $16.99 - $18.99 |
Homemade meatballs & onions
0
|
| Meat Special | $16.99 - $18.99 |
Sausage, pepperoni, bacon & ham
0
|
| Buffalo Chicken Pizza | $16.99 - $18.99 |
Hot & spicy chicken & mozzarella with a side of bleu cheese or ranch dressing
0
|
| Barbecue Chicken Pizza | $16.99 - $18.99 |
Grilled chicken covered in barbecue sauce & topped with mozzarella
0
|
| Philly Cheese Steak Pizza | $16.99 - $18.99 |
Shaved steak with sautéed green peppers & onions
0
|
| Greek Pizza | $16.99 - $18.99 |
Feta, red onions, spinach & black olives
0
|
| Sicilian Pizza | $15.99 |
0
|
| Desserts |
| Cannoli | $2.49 |
0
|
| New York Style Cheesecake | $3.49 |
0
|
| Chocolate Cake | $3.49 |
0
|
| Brownie A La Mode | $4.99 |
Served with 2 scoops of vanilla ice cream
0
|
| Zeppoles Basket | $3.49 |
0
|
* Disclaimer: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.
People Are Reading
-
13 Unmissable Thanksgiving Restaurant Deals in 2025Ready for a delicious & stress-free Thanksgiving 2025? Discover senior-friendly restaurant deals from Cracker Barrel, Perkins, and more, offering everything from classic turkey to exciting flavors! What will tempt you?
-
Top 12 Free Meals And Discounts For Veterans In 2025Celebrate Veterans Day 2025 with free meals and discounts from top restaurants like Applebee’s, Starbucks, and Outback Steakhouse—honoring service with gratitude and great food.
Hot Menus
- Applebee's Menu
- Arby's Menu
- Burger King Menu
- Chick-fil-A Menu
- Chipotle Mexican Grill Menu
- Cook Out Menu
- Domino's Pizza Menu
- Jersey Mike's Subs Menu
- KFC Menu
- McDonald's Menu
- Panera Bread Menu
- Papa Murphy's Menu
- Pizza Hut Menu
- Starbucks Coffee Menu
- Wendy's Menu
- Chili's Grill & Bar Menu
- Red Lobster Menu
- Texas Roadhouse Menu
- Bonefish Grill Menu
- Olive Garden Menu
Total Price