Menu With Price Menu Puritan Restaurant Menu

Puritan Restaurant Menu and Prices

4.4 based on 180 votes

Diner

Choose My State

Breakfast

One Egg	0	$4.35	any style MORE
Two Eggs	0	$4.70	any style MORE
Two Eggs	0	$6.95	with bacon, ham or sausage MORE
Corned Beef Hash And Eggs	0	$8.95
American Cheese Omelet	0	$6.95
Swiss Cheese Omelet	0	$6.95
Mozzarella Cheese Omelet	0	$6.95
Steak And Eggs	0	$8.95
Our Famous French Toast	0	$6.95
Our Famous Whole Wheat French Toast	0	$6.95

Our Famous Whole Wheat French Toast	0	$8.25	with bacon, ham or sausage MORE
Pancakes	0	$6.95
Pancakes	0	$8.25	with bacon, ham or sausage MORE
Whole Wheat Pancakes	0	$6.95
Whole Wheat Pancakes	0	$8.25	with bacon, ham or sausage MORE
One Egg On A Roll	0	$1.75	with your choice of cheese MORE
One Egg On A Roll	0	$3.25	with bacon, ham or sausage MORE
One Egg On A Roll	0	$3.95	with your choice of cheese MORE
Two Eggs	0	$2.50	on a roll MORE
Two Eggs	0	$3.95	with bacon, ham or sausage MORE

Two Eggs	0	$4.95	with choice of cheese MORE
Oatmeal	0	$4.75	made to order MORE
Oatmeal	0	$5.45	with bananas or honey MORE

Famous Omelets

All Omelettes Served With Potatoes And Toast

Our Granddaughter Maria-Jenny Omelet	0	$7.45	western omelet MORE
Our Grandson Nicholas Pantelis Omelet	0	$8.45	mushrooms and swiss cheese MORE
Nicoletta Omelet	0	$8.45	western with swiss cheese MORE
Absolut Omelet	0	$5.95	cream cheese and jelly MORE
Pete's Gourmet	0	$11.65	newborn french toast with eggs MORE
Puritan's Polo Club Omelet	0	$8.45	western with mozzarella cheese MORE
Member's Only Omelet	0	$9.45	roast beef with eggs MORE

John's Tow Away Zone	0	$11.65	french toast with eggs MORE
Pete's Parking Only	0	$11.65	newborn pancakes with eggs MORE
My Mom's And Pop's Omelet	0	$18.95	american, swiss, mozzarella cheese with ham, bacon and sausage MORE
Lifelong Friend's Omelet	0	$19.95	5 eggs, roast beef, ham, turkey, swiss and mozzarella cheese MORE
Moving Violation Omelet	0	$9.45	pastrami with american cheese MORE
Garbage Can Omelet	0	$14.95	onions, peppers, tomato, ham, swiss cheese and mushrooms MORE
Godson Teddy's Omelet	0	$10.95	mozzarella, ricotta cheese and ham MORE
Goddaughter Zoe's Omelet	0	$10.95	swiss, ricotta cheese and ham MORE
Godson Nicky Manny Omelet	0	$10.95	american, ricotta cheese and ham MORE
Goddaughter Reena Angelika	0	$9.45	pastrami with mozzarella cheese MORE

Dr. Hari's Omelet	0	$6.95	egg whites with any choice of cheese MORE
Sky's The Limit Omelet	0	$8.95	egg whites, swiss cheese and bacon MORE
Cocktail Omelet	0	$9.45	swiss cheese, sausage and fried onions MORE
On The Rocks	0	$7.95	hamburger and eggs MORE
Tequila Omelet	0	$9.45	swiss cheese, red pepper and ham MORE
Black Label Omelet	0	$9.45	ham, swiss cheese and tomato MORE
Fine Champagne Omelet	0	$9.45	pastrami with swiss cheese MORE
Life's A Beer Omelet	0	$9.45	roast beef with american cheese MORE
Dream On Omelet	0	$8.25	mozzarella, swiss and american cheese MORE
Hampton Bays Omelet	0	$8.95	onions, peppers and any choice of cheese MORE

Beverly Hills Omelet	0	$7.95	onions and peppers MORE
Bath Beach Omelet	0	$13.95	chicken cutlet with mozzarella cheese MORE
Dyker Heights Omelet	0	$13.95	meat loaf with any choice of cheese MORE
Shore Road Omelet	0	$12.95	ham, bacon, sausage and swiss cheese MORE
Puritan's Omelet	0	$9.45	turkey & swiss cheese MORE
John's Pizza Omelet	0	$7.95	mozzarella and tomato sauce MORE
From Us To You	0	$18.45	pancakes, french toast and eggs MORE
Established 1977 Omelet	0	$10.95	ham, sausage and american cheese MORE
86th Street Omelet	0	$9.45	ricotta with bacon, ham or sausage MORE
Greek Omelet	0	$9.75	feta cheese MORE

Always Greek To Me Omelet	0	$11.45	feta cheese, tomatoes and pepper MORE
Drivin And Cryin Special	0	$13.75	french toast and any choice of cheese omelet MORE
Just Cruisin Special	0	$13.75	pancakes and any choice of cheese omelet MORE
Busted Speeding Special	0	$18.95	french toast, pancakes and any choice of cheese omelet MORE
Off The Rocks	0	$8.95	cheeseburger and eggs MORE
Black Jack Omelet	0	$16.95	3 omelets same dish, 1 american, 1 swiss cheese and 1 mozzarella MORE
Non-Member's Only Omelet	0	$9.45	roast beef and mozzarella cheese MORE
Images And Words	0	$11.65	pancakes and eggs MORE
Corner Luncheonette Special	0	$11.65	eggs over, up and scramble MORE
We Cant's Dance Omelet	0	$14.95	3 eggs, whites or yellows, with any choice of cheese, ham, bacon and sausage MORE

Dozen Red Roses Omelet	0	$8.95	lettuce, tomato, mushroom and any choice of cheese MORE
Louie's Burning Down The House Omelet	0	$12.95	peppers, onions, red pepper, sausage with any choice of cheese MORE
Just You And I Omelet	0	$8.45	western with american cheese MORE
Thank You For Coming Special	0	$27.95	french toast, pancakes, 1 american, 1 swiss, 1 mozzarella omelet with bacon, ham, sausage, all served in 1 dish MORE
He Went Thataway Omelet	0	$7.95	mushrooms and onions MORE
"Whaddaya, Crazy" Omelet	0	$8.45	mushrooms and mozzarella cheese MORE
Wiggle It Omelet	0	$8.45	mushrooms and american cheese MORE
A Night To Remember Omelet	0	$9.45	turkey and american cheese MORE
Deuces Wild Omelet	0	$9.45	turkey and mozzarella cheese MORE
The Empire State Omelet	0	$18.95	grilled chicken with spinach and feta cheese. MORE

Hang Loose Zoe And Shasha Omelet	0	$11.95	feta cheese with bacon, ham or sausage MORE
Little Peter Omelet	0	$8.45	ham, bacon or sausage with tomato MORE
Born Spartan, Always A Spartan	0	$18.95	french toast with feta cheese and spinach MORE
Theo Bill And The Maria Omelet	0	$8.95	ham, tomato and onion MORE
Dr. John And Dr. Hari Omelet	0	$8.95	peppers, tomato and onion MORE

More Omelets And More

If You Prefer Egg Whites For Your Omelet, Please Specify, We Dont Use Egg Beaters

Our Granddaughter Eleni Catherini Omelet	0	$12.95	fresh spinach and mozzarella cheese MORE
Our Granddaughter Evanthea " Ava" Maria	0	$10.95	fresh spinach and mushrooms MORE
Brooklyn's Edition Omelet	0	$8.95	ham and american cheese MORE
Just Say The Words Omelet	0	$8.95	ham and swiss cheese MORE
Back To His Boyhood Omelet	0	$8.95	ham and mozzarella cheese MORE

The Doctor Is In Omelet	0	$8.95	bacon and american cheese MORE
Christina's Omelet	0	$8.95	bacon and swiss cheese MORE
I Dont Want To Grow Up Omelet	0	$8.95	bacon and mozzarella cheese MORE
Meet Me At The Puritan Omelet	0	$8.95	sausage and american cheese MORE
Estiatorio's Omelet	0	$8.95	sausage and swiss cheese MORE
Italian Omelet	0	$8.95	sausage and mozzarella cheese MORE
Once And Again Omelet	0	$9.95	fresh spinach MORE
Eh, " And They Say, Oh" Omelet	0	$12.95	fresh spinach and american cheese MORE
Forget About It Omelet	0	$12.95	fresh spinach and swiss cheese MORE
The Sky Is Falling Omelet	0	$14.95	fresh spinach, mushrooms and american cheese MORE

July 4 The 1776 Omelet	0	$14.95	fresh spinach, mushrooms and swiss cheese MORE
Thanks To Our Veterans Omelet	0	$14.95	fresh spinach, mushrooms and mozzarella cheese MORE
Place Says It All Omelet	0	$10.95	fresh spinach with fried onions MORE
Our Gang Omelet	0	$14.95	fresh spinach, fried onions and mozzarella cheese MORE
Yo Couz Omelet	0	$14.95	fresh spinach, fried onions and swiss cheese MORE
United Faces Omelet	0	$14.95	fresh spinach, fried onions and american cheese MORE
Happiness And Laughs Omelet	0	$10.95	fresh spinach and tomato MORE
Bay 8th And 86th Street Omelet	0	$14.95	fresh spinach, tomato and american cheese MORE
The Best Men's Omelet	0	$14.95	fresh spinach, tomato and swiss cheese MORE
Good Life Omelet	0	$14.95	fresh spinach, tomato and mozzarella cheese MORE

Man On The Moon Omelet	0	$14.95	fresh spinach, tomato and mushrooms MORE
That Was Then, This Is Now Omelet	0	$16.95	spinach, tomato, mushrooms and american cheese MORE
Cant Touch This Omelet	0	$16.95	fresh spinach, tomato, mushrooms and swiss cheese MORE
World Series Omelet	0	$16.95	fresh spinach, tomato, mushrooms and mozzarella cheese MORE
Life's Good Omelet	0	$14.95	grilled chicken cutlet with swiss cheese MORE
Love You Always Omelet	0	$14.95	grilled chicken with american cheese MORE
Always Grillin Omelet	0	$8.45	mushrooms and tomato MORE
Then Now Forever Pancakes	0	$9.95	with ice cream MORE
Children Of The World Omelet	0	$10.95	corned beef hash with choice of cheese MORE
Nick And Maria's French Toast	0	$9.45	with ice cream MORE

What's Up Brooklyn Omelet	0	$14.45	fresh spinach, feta cheese and tomato MORE
Pizza And A Six Pack Omelet	0	$14.45	fresh spinach, feta cheese and mushrooms MORE
I Can Speak Through My Tears	0	$15.95	fresh spinach, feta cheese, tomato and mushrooms MORE
" Hey, I Love You"	0	$15.95	french toast and pancakes with ice cream MORE
" My Wife Has Class"	0	$16.95	french toast with fresh spinach and mozzarella omelet MORE
Nicoletta With The Iron Hand	0	$16.95	pancakes, fresh spinach and swiss cheese omelet MORE
" Who Loves Ya" Baby	0	$12.95	fresh spinach and feta cheese omelet MORE
Giagia Maria Omelet	0	$7.95	roast beef, pastrami or turkey MORE
Papou Nicko Omelet	0	$7.95	mushroom and peppers MORE
Cheers My Friend	0	$15.95	grilled chicken with feta cheese and tomato omelet MORE

Hail Caesar	0	$18.45	double french toast with eggs MORE
I Pledge Allegiance	0	$18.45	double order pancakes with eggs MORE
Victoria, No Dancing In The Aisles	0	$17.45	pancakes with spinach and feta cheese omelet MORE
Just Sit Down And Eat	0	$15.95	meat loaf with feta cheese and tomato omelet MORE
" Bubba" And " Bebba" Omelet	0	$17.95	spinach, onions, mushroom, tomato, bacon and mozzarella cheese MORE
Hope Catherine Omelet	0	$14.95	spinach, ham, and mozzarella cheese MORE
Victoria And Nicholas Cats Omelet	0	$14.95	spinach, bacon and mozzarella cheese MORE
Evanthea " Ava" " Ivanka" Omelet	0	$14.95	spinach and ricotta and mozzarella cheese MORE
Love You Maria " Marake" Omelet	0	$15.95	spinach, mushroom, ham and swiss cheese MORE
Love You Too Eleni My Dear	0	$14.95	spinach, bacon and ricotta cheese MORE

Our Three Granddaughters Omelet	0	$17.95	spinach, onions, mushrooms, tomato, feta cheese and mozzarella cheese MORE
Mia Omorfe Kopella Omelet	0	$16.95	spinach, mushrooms, ham and mozzarella cheese MORE
Nicolette Marie And Nicholas Vasileios Omelet	0	$14.95	ricotta cheese feta cheese and spinach MORE
Thanks To Our Babysitters	0	$18.95	french toast with ricotta and mozzarella cheese with spinach omelet MORE
Our Koumbaro And Koumbara Omelet	0	$14.50	swiss cheese, spinach, tomatoes, onions and peppers MORE
Best Mom In The World	0	$24.95	pancakes, french toast with spinach, feta cheese and tomato omelet MORE
Through The Years Omelet	0	$19.95	grilled chicken, feta cheese, spinach, tomato and mushrooms MORE
Louie " Our Grillman" Always Grilling Special	0	$28.95	french toast, pancakes with ricotta cheese, spinach, bacon, sausage and mozzarella cheese omelet MORE
Yes, Yes, We Know Our Breakfast Is The Best	0	$19.95	french toast with pastrami, mozzarella cheese, tomato, ricotta cheese and spinach omelet MORE
300 Plus One " My Son Nicholas	0	$18.95	french toast with meatloaf, spinach, feta cheese, tomato and pepper omelet MORE

All American Sandwich

Make Your Sandwich Deluxe For $3.50 Additional And Get French Fries, Lettuce And Tomato Any Sandwich On Pita Bread $0.75 Extra, Bagel $0.75 Extra, Lettuce And Tomato $0.75 Extra, With Bacon $1.95 Extra

Grill Cheese	0	$5.95
Grill Swiss	0	$5.95
Grill Mozzarella	0	$5.95
Bacon, Lettuce And Tomato	0	$5.95
Tuna Salad	0	$6.45
Chicken Salad	0	$6.45
Western	0	$5.95
Egg Salad	0	$4.45
Individual Tuna	0	$4.95
Individual Sardine	0	$4.95

Hard Boiled Eggs	0	$3.95
Ham And Choice Of Cheese	0	$8.45

Classic Burgers

Reg / Dlx.

Puritan's Hamburger	0	$4.50 - $6.75
Puritan's Cheeseburger	0	$4.95 - $7.45
Puritan's Pizza Burger	0	$5.25 - $7.45
Bacon Hamburger	0	$5.35 - $7.75
Bacon Cheeseburger	0	$5.75 - $8.95
Swiss Burger	0	$4.95 - $7.95
Mushroom Burger	0	$5.25 - $7.75
Mushroom Cheese Burger	0	$5.75 - $7.95

Mushroom Bacon Burger	0	$6.85 - $9.45
Mushroom Bacon Cheeseburger	0	$9.95 - $7.85
Lonely Men	0	$6.50 - $8.95	fresh spinach, garlic and onions on a burger MORE
19th Hole	0	$6.95 - $9.25	fresh spinach, garlic, onions and mozzarella on a burger MORE
" Shorty" John	0	$10.75 - $8.25	fresh spinach, garlic, onions, mozzarella cheese and mushrooms on a burger MORE
Peter On The Job	0	$10.95 - $8.95	bacon, fresh spinach, garlic, onions, grilled tomatoes and mushrooms on a burger MORE
" Two If By Sea"	0	$11.95 - $9.95	bacon fresh spinach, garlic, onions, grilled tomatoes, mushrooms and choice of cheese on a burger MORE
You Like, " Please Take Me"	0	$11.95 - $14.95	2 burgers in 1, with bacon, fresh spinach, garlic, onions, grilled tomatoes, mushrooms and choice of cheese on a hard roll MORE

Specialty Deluxe Burgers

John's Hamburger	0	$8.95	ham and cheese deluxe MORE
Pete's Hamburger	0	$8.95	roast beef and cheese deluxe MORE

Our Famous Pizza Burger Deluxe	0	$7.95
Mozzarella Burger Deluxe	0	$8.95	with mozzarella on fries MORE
Bay 8th Street Cheeseburger Deluxe	0	$8.95	pastrami and cheese MORE
Mixed Cheeseburger Deluxe	0	$8.95	swiss, mozzarella and american MORE
Twin Burger Deluxe	0	$8.50
Twin Burger Deluxe	0	$9.95	with bacon MORE
Twin Cheeseburger Deluxe	0	$10.25
Twin Cheeseburger Deluxe	0	$10.95	with bacon MORE
Chicken Fingers	0	$8.95
Chicken Fingers	0	$9.45	with french fries MORE

Chicken Fingers	0	$9.95	with cheese on french fries MORE

Special Sandwiches

1. Pete's Individual Tuna	0	$7.95	on pita bread mixed with mayonnaise, lettuce, tomato and onion MORE
2. 86th St. And Bay 8th St. Individual Sardine On Pita Bread	0	$6.95	sardines with mustard, onion, lettuce, tomato on pita bread MORE
3. John's Grilled Chicken Cutlet	0	$8.95	with lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on pita bread MORE
4. Pete's Grilled Chicken Cutlet	0	$8.95	chicken cutlet with lettuce tomato and mustard on pita bread MORE
5. Bay 8th Street Grilled Chicken Cutlet	0	$8.95	chicken cutlet with any choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on pita bread MORE
6. P. J. S Chicken Grilled Parmigiana	0	$8.45	on pita bread MORE
7. Member's Only Sandwich	0	$9.45	with roast beef, gravy, mayonnaise, choice of cheese, lettuce and tomato on a roll MORE
8. Non - Member's Only Sandwich	0	$9.45	roast beef, mustard, choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion on a roll MORE
9. John's Goulash	0	$5.25	2 egg cheese omelet style with any choice of cheese, potatoes, bacon or ham on a roll MORE

10. Pete's Goulash	0	$5.25	2 eggs over soft with any choice of cheese, potatoes, bacon or ham on a roll MORE
11. Puritan's Famous	0	$9.45	ham grilled with any choice of cheese, mustard, mayonnaise, lettuce and tomato on a roll MORE
12. Bay 8th Street Special	0	$9.45	grilled pastrami with any choice of cheese onion mustard lettuce and tomato on a roll MORE
13. Corner Lunch Omlette Special	0	$14.95	roast beef, virginia ham with any choice of cheese, pastrami, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, gravy and mustard on a roll MORE
14. My Father In Law	0	$8.95	grilled chicken with fresh spinach, garlic and onions MORE
15. But, My Mother In Law Is Better	0	$9.95	grilled chicken with fresh spinach, garlic, onions and choice of cheese MORE
16. Hope Catherine	0	$8.75	grilled chicken with fresh roasted peppers MORE
16. Hope Catherine	0	$9.95	with choice of cheese (american, mozzarella or swiss cheese) MORE
17. Peter & Kathy And The Little One Victoria	0	$8.95	grilled chicken with grilled mushrooms and garlic MORE
17. Peter & Kathy And The Little One Victoria	0	$9.75	with choice of cheese (american, mozzarella or swiss cheese) MORE

18. Tommy And Helen	0	$9.95	grilled chicken with roasted peppers, mozzarella, mushrooms and garlic MORE
19. Nicolette Marie And Nicholas Vasileios	0	$9.50	grilled chicken with fresh spinach, garlic, onion and mushrooms MORE
19. Nicolette Marie And Nicholas Vasileios	0	$10.95	with choice of cheese MORE
20. " We Don't Have Your Hub Caps"	0	$13.95	grilled chicken with roasted peppers, mozzarella, spinach, garlic, onions and mushrooms. MORE
21. The Boys Of Bay 8th St	0	$8.45	grilled chicken with fresh spinach and garlic MORE
21. The Boys Of Bay 8th St	0	$8.95	with choice of cheese, american, mozzarella or swiss cheese MORE
22. Honey I'm Home	0	$8.25	grilled chicken with lettuce, tomato and honey mustard on a pita MORE

Triple Decker Clubs

Your Choice Of Meat Or Grilled Chicken Cutlet	0	$10.45	with bacon, lettuce and tomato MORE
Your Choice Of Meat Or Grilled Chicken Cutlet	0	$11.45	with choice of cheese MORE
Your Choice Of Salad - Tuna Or Chicken	0	$9.45	with bacon, lettuce and tomato MORE

Your Choice Of Salad - Tuna Or Chicken	0	$10.45	with choice of cheese MORE

Puritan's Meat Sandwiches And Roasts

Sandwich $8.95 / Open Plate $13.45 / Plate $14.75, Plates Are Served With Potatoes, Vegetable And Bread Lettuce And Tomato $0.50 Extra, Pita Bread, $0.50 Extra.

Leg Of Lamb	Price may varies	monday MORE
Half Of Roast Chicken	Price may varies	tuesday and saturday MORE
Our Famous Fresh Ham	Price may varies	wednesday MORE
Corn Beef And Cabbage	Price may varies	thursday MORE
Filet, Shrimp Or Scallops Sandwich	Price may varies	friday MORE
Combination	$17.95	(fresh fish, not frozen). pot roast, brisket of beef, pastrami, virginia ham, grilled chicken cutlet, london broil, meat loaf. MORE

Our Grand Children Special $27.95

Maria, Eleni, Nicholas & Ava (No Sharing) If You Could Finish, It's Free! If Not, It Costs You. Includes:

One Order French Toast	0	Price may varies
One Order Pancakes	0	Price may varies
One Choice Of Cheese Omelet	0	Price may varies

Bacon	0	Price may varies
Ham And Sausage	0	Price may varies
Home Fries	0	Price may varies	large order MORE
Large Choice Of Juice	0	Price may varies
Coffee And Small Glass Of Water	0	Price may varies

Our Famous Salads

Made To Order, Served With Your Choice Of Bread

1. Our Famous Greek Salad	0	$14.95
2. Greek Salad Mixed	0	$15.95	with individual tuna MORE
3. Our Overstuffed Chef Salad	0	$15.95
4. Tuna Salad Platter	0	$9.95
5. Individual Tuna Salad Platter	0	$9.95

6. Individual Sardine Platter	0	$9.95
7. Egg Salad Platter	0	$8.95
8. Caesar Salad	0	$13.95	with individual tuna MORE
9. Pete's Individual Tuna Platter	0	$11.95
10. John's Grilled Chicken Platter	0	$11.95
11. Chicken Salad Platter	0	$9.95
12. Ava's Grilled Chicken	0	$16.95	with greek salad MORE
13. Maria And Elenas Famous Caesar Salad	0	$11.95	with roasted peppers MORE
14. Our Grandson Nicholas Pantelis Caesar Salad	0	$14.95	with grilled chicken and roasted peppers MORE

Snacks, Side Orders And Extras

Our Famous Home Style Onion Rings	0	$6.95 - $8.95	made fresh daily, MORE

Our Famous Home Style Onion Rings	0	$7.95 - $9.95	with any choice of cheese MORE
Our Famous French Fries	0	$3.95 - $4.95
Our Famous French Fries	0	$4.95 - $6.25	with any choice of cheese MORE
Our Famous Homestyle Home Fries	0	$3.45
Homestyle Cole Slaw	0	$0.95
Vegetable	0	$1.25
Lettuce & Tomato	0	$1.75
Rice Pudding	0	$1.95	in season MORE
Melons	0	$2.45	in season MORE
Feta Cheese	0	$3.45

Spinach	0	$4.95	with garlic MORE
Bacon, Ham Or Sausage	0	$2.75

Beverages

Our Famous Brooklyn's Best Egg Cream $2.95

Sodas	Price may varies	choice of cans MORE
Malted Or Shake	$3.95
Malted Or Shake	$4.95	extra thick MORE
Juices	$3.95 - $3.45
Choice Of Snapple	Price may varies
Coffee	Price may varies
Tea	Price may varies
Sanka	Price may varies
Iced Coffee	$2.25
Iced Tea	$2.25
Milk	$3.45
Chocolate Milk	$3.95

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.