New York Bagel Company Menu and Prices

4.5 based on 132 votes

Choose My State

Bagels
Plain
0
$8.85 - $0.80
Sesame Seed
0
$8.85 - $0.80
Everything
0
$8.85 - $0.80
Sun-dried Tomato
0
$8.85 - $0.80
Blueberry
0
$8.85 - $0.80
Cinnamon Raisin
0
$8.85 - $0.80
Banana Nut
0
$8.85 - $0.80
Sugar Buster Wheat
0
$8.85 - $0.80
Asiago Cheese
0
$8.85 - $0.80
Honey Whole Wheat
0
$8.85 - $0.80
Poppy Seed
0
$8.85 - $0.80
Garlic
0
$8.85 - $0.80
Onion
0
$8.85 - $0.80
Cajun
0
$8.85 - $0.80
Pumpernickel
0
$2.50
Extra for sliced bagels
MORE
Gourmet Cream Cheese
Freshly whipped & made with lite cream cheese
Plain or Lite
0
$1.39 - $4.59
Garden Veggie
0
$1.79 - $5.99
Garlic & Herb
0
$1.79 - $5.99
Spinach & Artichoke
0
$1.79 - $5.99
Pecan Delight
0
$1.99 - $6.59
Strawberry
0
$1.69 - $5.99
Breakfast Bagel, Biscuit, or Croissant
Toasted with egg, american cheese and your choice of following
Ham, Bacon, or Sausage
0
$3.49
Extra meat add $1.00, extra egg add $0.50, extra cheese $0.45-$0.75
MORE
Soup du Jour
Served with bagel chips and veggie cream cheese dip
Soup du Jour
0
$4.50
Soup du Jour with Sandwich with Bagel Chips
0
$3.50
Salads
The Big Salad
0
$5.99
Romain lettuce, tomato, mushrooms, carrots, green bell peppers, purple onions, and mozzarella cheese. Served with bagel
MORE
The Big Salad with Chicken or Turkey
0
$2.50
Side Salad
0
$3.99
Bagel Pizza’s
Little Italy
0
$5.99
Our own pizza sauce topped with mozzarella cheese, italian seasoning, and a dash of oregano. Add pepperoni or mushroom $0.45
MORE
Veggie Pizza
0
$6.89
Little italy plus mushroom, green bell peppers, onions, jalapenos
MORE
Village Pizza
0
$5.99
Fresh spinach, olive oil, mozzarella, garlic, and roma tomatoes
MORE
Little Italy
0
$5.99
Our own pizza sauce topped with mozzarella cheese, Italian seasoning, and a dash of oregano. Add pepperoni or mushroom add $0.45
MORE
Veggie Pizza
0
$6.89
Little Italy plus mushroom, green bell peppers, onions, jalapenos
MORE
Village Pizza
0
$5.99
Fresh spinach, olive oil, mozzarella, garlic, and roma tomatoes
MORE
Create Your Own
Served on a bagel, croissant, whole wheat wrap, or bread with bagel chips and veggie cream cheese dip or potato chips and a pickle spear. Wheat wrap or hoagie add $0.75, extra meat add $2.75, add cheese swiss, provolone $0.45-.$0.75. Mozzarella, american,
Turkey, Ham or Roast Beef
0
$6.19
Spiced Turkey
0
$6.29
Pastrami, Salami, or Corned Beef
0
$6.29
Taste of Philly
Served with bagel chips and dip or chips and a pickle spear
Philly Cheese Steak
0
$7.49
Grilled rib-eye steak or chicken. Served with grilled onions, green bell peppers & melted provolone cheese. Dressed at your request
MORE
Italian Hoagie
0
$7.49
Salami, capicola ham, provolone cheese, onion, lettuce, tomato, and vinegar
MORE
Pizza Steak
0
$7.49
Rib-eye steak with pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese. Dressed at your request
MORE
Specialty Sandwiches
Served on a bagel, croissant, bread, or whole wheat wrap $0.75. Includes bagel chips with veggie cream cheese dip or potato chips and a pickle spear. $0.25 Extra pickle spear, $0.45-$0.75 substitute cheese, hoagie $0.75
Manhattan Skyscraper
0
$6.79
¼ Pound of hot pastrami, melted mozzarella cheese, deli mustard, lettuce, tomato, and finely shredded onions
MORE
Broadway’s Best
0
$6.89
¼ Pound of prime roast beef, melted muenster cheese, dijon mustard, mayo, lettuce, and tomato
MORE
Brooklyn Bomber
0
$6.89
Smoked sliced chicken breast, havarti cheese, spicy mayo and tomato
MORE
Tavern on the Green
0
$6.89
¼ Pound of spiced turkey, melted swiss cheese, dijon mustard, and alfalfa sprouts
MORE
Staten Island
0
$6.79
Grilled lemon chicken, melted american cheese, mayo, mustard, lettuce, tomato, pickles, and onions
MORE
The Cabbie
0
$6.69
¼ Pound corned beef, melted swiss cheese, deli mustard and onions
MORE
Mulberry
0
$6.79
Capacola ham, salami, provolone cheese, vinaigrette dressing, lettuce, tomato and onions
MORE
Twin Towers
0
$5.39
Your choice of two cheese melted, lettuce and tomato
MORE
The New Yorker
0
$7.69
Nova lox smoked salmon, cream cheese, red onions, and capers
MORE
New York Club
0
$6.99
¼ Pound smoked turkey, bacon, mayo, swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and sprouts
MORE
BLT
0
$5.89
Bacon, american cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo
MORE
Veggie Bagel Sandwich
0
$5.99
Choice of cream cheese or sliced cheese with lettuce, tomato, green peppers, onions, alfalfa sprouts, mushroom and pickles
MORE
Tuna Salad
0
$5.89
Dressed at your request. Made with pickles, jalapenos, mayo, celery
MORE
Chicken Salad
0
$5.99
Dressed at your request. Made with mesquite chicken breast, celery and spices
MORE
Muffalatta - Whole
0
$11.99
On sesame seed bun. Salami, ham, provolone cheese, olive mix and lettuce
MORE
Muffalatta - Half
0
$7.99
On sesame seed bun. Salami, ham, provolone cheese, olive mix and lettuce
MORE
Extras
Bag of Bagel Chips
0
$4.49
Bagel Chips & Dip
0
$4.79
Cinnamon Rolls
0
$1.99
Bagel Bites
0
$0.50
Bagel Bites - Dozen
0
$5.64
Muffin
0
$1.89
Extra Dip
0
$0.79
Zapps
0
$0.60

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

Total Price