The Cull House Restaurant Prices in Sayville, NY 11782

4.0 based on 65 votes

Hours of Operation

  • Mon: 12:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  • Tue: 12:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  • Wed: 12:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  • Thu: 12:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  • Fri: 12:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  • Sat: 12:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  • Sun: 12:00 pm - 9:00 pm

Restaurant Menu

Appetizers
Calamari & Hot Cherry Pepper Rings $11.00
with balsamic reduction
0
Baked Clams $8.00
chopped & stuffed cherrystones
0
Clams Casino $9.00
littleneck clams broiled with butter, garlic, peppers and bacon
0
Oysters Rockefeller $11.00
four local oysters baked with spinach fennel topping
0
Steamed Hardshell Clams or Prince Edward Island Mussels $12.00
your choice of drawn butter and lemon, Posillipo (tomato & basil) or Luciano (garlic, butter & white wine sauce)
0
Jane's Long Island Steamers $13.00
soft shell clams
0
Long Island Crab Cake $11.00
hot smoked paprika aioli & tartar sauce
0
Buffalo Chicken Wings $10.00
with bleu cheese dressing, celery and carrot sticks - mild, medium or hot!
0
Fried Calamari $11.00
with marinara sauce
0
Fried Shrimp $9.00
orange coconut sauce
0
Battered Mozzarella Sticks $7.00
with marinara sauce
0
Chicken Fingers $7.00
with honey mustard dipping sauce or Buffalo style
0
Garlic Bread $4.00
0
Clams Casino $9.00
whole littleneck clams, broiled with butter, garlic, bell peppers and bacon
0
Oysters Rockefeller $8.00
four local oysters baked with spinach fennel topping
0
Steamed hard-shell clams, or mussels $10.00
with either drawn butter, posillipo (tomato & basil) or Luciano (garlic butter & white wine sauce)
0
Local clams on the half shell $6.00 - $10.00
0
Local Oysters on the Half Shell with mignonette $8.00 - $15.00
0
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail $9.00
0
Cold Shellfish Combo $11.00
2 jumbo shrimp, 3 oysters & 4 clams
0
Shrimp Cocktail  
classic cocktail sauce
0
Crab Cake  
tartar sauce, hot smoked paprika aioli
0
Clams Casino  
grilled crouton
0
Fried Calamari  
marinara sauce
0
Sliced Sirloin  
garlic toast, horseradish cream
0
Mozzarella en Carroza  
fried mozzarella, tomato pesto, balsamic
0
Garlic Shrimp  
grilled crostini, tomato, artichoke, white wine butter
0
Mushroom Ragout  
roasted mushrooms, ciabatta toast, parmesan, thyme, truffle oil
0
Mussels Luciano  
steamed mussels, white wine-butter garlic sauce
0
Honey Calamari $12.00
Fried with toasted sesame seeds and scallions
0
House Smoked Mahi & Tuna Dip $12.00
served with pickled jalapeños, red onions and crackers
0
Raw Bar
Local Clams on the Half Shell (raw)* $8.00 - $13.00
0
Local Oysters on the Half Shell (raw)* $11.00 - $20.00
0
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail $9.00
0
Cold Shellfish Combo $14.00
2 jumbo shrimp, 3 oysters & 4 clams
0
Large Shrimp Cocktail $33.00
Cocktail Sauce, Lemons
0
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail $43.00
Cocktail Sauce, Lemons
0
Littleneck Clams on Half shell $32.00
Cocktail Sauce, Lemons
0
Oysters on Half Shell $35.00
Cocktail Sauce, Lemons
0
Lobster Cocktail $79.00
Cooked and Chilled. Lemons and Dijonaise Sauce
0
Soups
add a bread bowl ... $2.50
New England Clam Chowder $5.50
0
Manhattan Clam Chowder $5.50
0
Lobster Bisque $7.50
0
Salads
add shrimp or chicken (grilled, broiled or blackened) ...8 add tuna or salmon (grilled, broiled or blackened) ...10
The Wedge $7.00
iceberg, applewood smoked bacon, cherry tomato, bleu cheese, parmesan peppercorn dressing
0
Cull Salad $7.00 - $9.00
mesclun greens, candied walnuts, dried cranberries, goat cheese and raspberry vinaigrette
0
Classic Caesar Salad $7.00 - $9.00
hearts of romaine lettuce, shaved parmesan, garlic crouton and caesar dressing
0
Summer Salad $7.00 - $9.00
julienned romaine, shaved scallions, cherry tomatoes & lemon dressing
0
Gluten Free Wedge $7.00
iceberg, applewood smoked bacon, cherry tomato, blue cheese vinaigrette
0
Summer Salad $5.00 - $8.00
julienned romaine, shaved scallions, cherry tomatoes, lemon dressing
0
Lobster
served with choice of french fries, baked potato or rice pilaf and vegetable. any lobster can be crabmeat stuffed & broiled for an additional $8
1 1/4 Pound Steamed $26.00
0
1 1/2 Pound Steamed $32.00
0
2 Pound $42.00
0
8oz Brazilian Lobster Tail $29.00
drawn butter
0
Lobster Roll $18.00
maine lobster meat, classic dressing, garlic toasted potato roll
0
Cull House Lobster Clam Bake $33.00
1 1/4 lb lobster, littleneck clams, mussels, corn on the cob, sausage, baby potatoes
0
Entrees
all served with choice of potato or rice and vegetable
Broiled Fisherman's Platter $22.00
shrimp, bay scallops, crab cake, baked clam, catch of the day
0
Baja Cod Tacos $18.00
3 tacos, Corona battered cod, guacamole, citrus slaw, Baja sauce
0
Fried Fisherman's Platter $21.00
shrimp, bay scallops, clams and filet with choice of two sauces: lemon garlic aioli, hot smoked paprika aioli, orange coconut, tartar, marinara, cocktail
0
Shellfish Penne ala Vodka $22.00
shrimp, crabmeat, scallops, garlic croutons
0
Seafood Shepherd's Pie $22.00
Maine lobster meat, scallops, shrimp, peas, carrots, potatoes, chopped egg, with whipped potato and Gruyere cheese topping Shrimp Francaise egg battered shrimp, lemon, butter & garlic
0
Cedar Plank Whiskey Salmon $20.00
with a Kentucky bourbon glaze
0
Broiled Flounder $20.00 - $24.00
garlic, butter, grilled lemon and parsley crumb
0
Sesame Crusted Yellow Fin Tuna $24.00
Vietnamese dipping sauce
0
Cull House Chicken $18.00
sautèed chicken breast with artichokes, capers, oven dried tomatoes in a lemon wine butter sauce
0
8oz Filet Mignon* $31.00 - $49.00
garlic butter
0
Fish & Chips $18.00
beer battered cod and steak fries served with malt vinegar
0
Seafood Pot Bake $25.00
snow crab legs, shrimp, mussels, scallops, little neck clams, haddock, potatoes, tomato seafood broth
0
White Clam Sauce $18.00 - $21.00
while littleneck clams, manila clams, parsley, lemon, garlic, white wine butter sauce over linguine
0
Linguine Frutti di Mare $24.00
shrimp, scallops, mussels, clams, calamari, white wine tomato sauce ... can be made fra diavolo style
0
Broiled Bay Scallops $22.00
parsley crumb, grilled lemon
0
Classic Jumbo Shrimp Scampi $22.00
garlic butter, lemon, white wine sauce, crispino crouton
0
Crabmeat Stuffed Jumbo Shrimp $22.00
beurre blanc, parsley crumb, lemon
0
Shrimp Francaise $24.00
egg battered shrimp in lemon butter wine sauce
0
King Crab Legs $32.00
1 1/4 lb, steamed
0
Cull House Fried Seafood $18.00
choice of one seafood and two sauces: shrimp, clam strips, flounder, calamari, bay scallops tartar, cocktail, marinara, orange coconut, Cull house aioli
0
Long Island Crab Cakes $20.00
jumbo cakes with claw crab meat, lemon-mayonnaise bread crumb with choice of cocktail, tartar or hot smoked paprika aioli
0
Grilled 8oz Hamburger* $11.00
lettuce, tomato, onion, organic ciabatta roll
0
Gluten Free Fish & Chips $19.00
gluten free beer battered cod, baked potato, cole slaw
0
Cull House Fried Basket $18.00
shrimp, clam strips, flounder, calamari or bay scallops. includes french fries and cole slaw
0
Paella Valenciana (GF) $25.00
Shrimp, clams, mussels,scallops, chicken, chorizo, peas, saffron rice. Served with a garden salad.
0
Local Striped Bass Fillet (GF) $27.00
Steamed in banana leaf, with cajun vegetable butter.
0
Maryland Soft Shell Crabs $25.00
sautèed or fried
0
Grilled Shrimp over Spinach Strawberry Salad (GF) $21.00
Toasted pecans, gorgonzola,cantaloupe, honey balsamic vinaigrette.
0
Broiled Halibut Tacos $21.00
Peach salsa and mango aioli.
0
Sandwiches
all served with cole slaw and choice of french fries, potato salad or rice
Lobster Roll $23.00
Maine lobster meat, classic dressing, garlic toasted potato roll
0
Lobster Grilled Cheese $22.00
maine lobster meat, aged cheddar cheese and garlic herb butter on panini bread
0
Lunch Baja Taco $13.00
two tacos, corona battered cod, guacamole, citrus slaw, Baja sauce
0
Fried Fish Sandwich $14.00
fish of the day, sliced avocado, chipotle mayo
0
Shrimp Roll $15.00
jumbo gulf prawns, classic dressing, garlic toasted potato roll
0
Sliced Ahi Tuna Sandwich* $15.00
pan seared sesame crusted tuna, scallions, mesclun greens, tomato and spicy hot smoked paprika aioli
0
Crab Roll $13.00
jumbo lump & sweet claw crab meat, classic dressing on a garlic toasted potato roll
0
Fried Clam Roll $12.00
fried clam strips, tartar sauce, garlic toasted potato roll
0
Grilled Chicken Club $14.00
8oz chicken breast, applewood smoked bacon, swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion & mayo
0
South Bay Crab Cake Sandwich $14.00
mesclun greens, tomato and tartar sauce
0
Lunch Salads
over a cull salad, garden salad or Caesar salad. Choice of grilled, broiled, blackened or sautèed:
Flounder, Salmon, Shrimp or Chicken $14.00
0
Yellow Fin Tuna $17.00
0
Entrées
All of our lobsters, king crab legs and Brazilian lobster tails are available steamed or broiled gluten free to order!
Cedar Plank Salmon $19.00
roasted cedar plank salmon with garlic butter
0
Broiled Flounder $19.00
garlic butter, grilled lemon
0
Seafood Shepherd's Pie $19.00
Maine lobster meat, scallops, shrimp, peas, carrots, potatoes, chopped egg, whipped potato & gruyere cheese topping
0
Cull House Chicken $18.00
sautéed chicken breast, artichokes, capers, oven dried tomatoes, white wine lemon butter sauce
0
8oz. Filet Mignon* $39.00
garlic butter 26 or with 8oz. Brazilian lobster tail
0
Gluten Free Broiled Fisherman $19.00
basa, scallops, shrimp, 6 clams casino
0
Classic Jumbo Shrimp Scampi $19.00
garlic butter, lemon, white wine sauce
0
Gluten Free Fish and Chips $17.00
gluten free beer battered cod, baked potato, tartar sauce, cole slaw
0
Cull House Lobster Clam Bake $29.00
1 1/4 pound lobster, littleneck clams, mussels, corn on the cob, baked potato, sausage, scampi butter sauce
0
On Tap
Blue Point Toasted Lager  
0
Blue Point Hoptical Illusion  
0
Stella Artois  
0
Guinness Stout  
0
Sierra Nevada Pale Ale  
0
Blue Point Summer Ale  
0
Bottles
Budweiser  
0
Heineken  
0
Heineken Light  
0
Michelob Ultra  
0
Redeberger Pilsner  
0
Coors Light  
0
Corona Extra  
0
Amstel Light  
0
Beck's NA (non-alcoholic)  
0
Redbridge  
0
Soups and Salads
$4.50 per person. Choice of all:
Manhattan Clam Chowder  
0
New England Clam Chowder  
0
Lobster Bisque  
additional $2 per person
0
Soup of the Day  
0
Cull Salad  
field greens, dried cranberries, goat cheese, candied walnuts, raspberry vinaigrette
0
Classic Caesar Salad  
0
Entree
$16 per person. Select five:
Broiled Flounder  
grilled lemon, parsley-crumb
0
Crabmeat Stuffed Flounder  
grilled lemon, white wine butter
0
Parmesan Crusted Haddock  
tomato beurre fondue
0
Five Herb Rubbed Salmon  
horseradish-mustard cream sauce
0
Grilled Yellowfin Tuna  
Vietnamese dipping sauce
0
Pan Roasted Chicken  
choice of piccata, francaise or marsala
0
Cull Chicken  
capers, shallots, artichokes, oven dried tomatoes, white wine butter sauce
0
Chicken Saltimbocca  
sautéed chicken breast, prosciutto, tomato, fresh mozzarella
0
Marinated Sliced Steak  
frizzled onions, demi-glace
0
Seafood Ala Vodka  
shrimp, bay scallops, crabmeat, penne pasta
0
Classic Linguini Clam Sauce  
white or Red
0
Shrimp Puttanesca  
shrimp, spicy tomato-caper sauce, shaved parmesan
0
Baja Cod Tacos  
Corona battered cod, guacamole, citrus slaw, Baja sauce
0
Fish and Chips  
Guinness battered Atlantic cod, steak fries, tartar sauce
0
Seafood Shepherd's Pie  
Maine lobster meat, scallops, shrimp, peas, carrots, potatoes, chopped egg, with whipped potato & Gruyere cheese
0
Lobster Clam Bake $25.00
0
1 1/4 lb Lobster Bake  
littleneck clams, mussels, sausage, corn, baby potatoes, scampi butter
0
Dessert Menu
$3.50 per person. Select three:
Brownie Sundae  
warm brownie served ala mode with chocolate sauce and whipped cream
0
Chocolate Mousse  
whipped cream, chocolate chips
0
N.Y. Cheesecake  
whipped cream, raspberry sauce
0
Mini Chocolate Mousse  
whipped cream, chocolate chips
0
Mini Key Lime Pie  
Lime wedge, graham cracker crumb, whipped cream
0
Mini Strawberry Pound Cake  
pound cake, strawberries, strawberry sauce whipped cream
0
Mini Cheesecake Trifle  
N.Y. cheesecake, strawberry sauce, whipped cream
0
Apple Crisp  
apples baked with brown sugar, cinnamon and streusel topping served warm
0
Ice Cream  
chocolate or vanilla
0
Drink Packages
Soda and Juice $2.50
0
Beer, Wine and Soda $14.00
0
Beer, Wine, Soda and Open Bar $20.00
0
Beer, Wine, Soda and Premium Open Bar $24.00
0
Appetizer Trays
Baked Clams $24.00
0
Clams Casino $36.00
0
Oysters Rockefeller $32.00
0
Steamed Clams $39.00
Possillipo, Luciano, or Butter and Lemon
0
PEI Mussels $29.00
Possillipo, Luciano, or Butter and Lemon
0
Fried Calamari $29.00
Marinara, Balsamic Glaze, Cull House Aioli
0
Lump Crab Cakes $49.00
Lemons, Tartar Sauce, Cocktail Sauce
0
Dinner Trays
Stuffed Flounder $39.00
with Crabmeat Stuffing
0
Stuffed Shrimp $39.00
with Crabmeat Stuffing
0
Grilled Salmon $59.00
with mango-chili salsa
0
Herb Crusted Salmon $49.00
with whole grain mustard sauce
0
Pan Seared Sesame Tuna $59.00
with Vietnamese dipping sauce
0
Seafood Fra Diavlo $49.00
over linguine - hot, medium or mild
0
Linguine $39.00
with Clam Sauce (Possillipo or Luciano)
0
"Angry Shrimp" Linguine $49.00
0
Penne ala Vodka $49.00
with shrimp, scallops and crabmeat
0
Chicken Francaise, Piccata or Marsala $39.00
0
Herb Roasted Half Chicken $59.00
with grilled lemons
0
Asian Marinated Sliced Skirt Steaks $65.00
with grilled scallions
0
Slow Roasted Sweet and Sour Pork Loin $59.00
with pineapple relish
0
Side Dishes
Baked Potatoes $19.99
0
Rice Pilaf $25.00
0
Potato Salad $24.00
0
Cole Slaw $19.00
0
Sautéed Seasonal Vegetable $22.00
0
Grilled Vegetables $24.00
0
Roasted Vegetables $24.00
0
Linguini Garlic and Oil $25.00
0
Clam Bakes
fully cooked and ready to serve
Lobster Clam Bake $349.00
10 -1 1/4 lb Maine lobsters, 5 dozen steamed littlenecks, 5 lbs PEI mussels, 2 lbs grilled sausage, 10 ears corn, 2 pounds roasted baby potatoes, ciabatta bread, 1 quart scampi butter
0
Shore Dinner $399.00
10 - 1 1/4 pound Maine lobsters, 10 roasted half chickens, 3 lbs steamers (soft shell clams), 5 lbs PEI mussels, 2 lbs grilled sausage, 10 ears corn, 2 lbs roasted baby potatoes, ciabatta bread, 1 qu
0
Premium Lobster Dinner $499.00
6 - 1 1/2 lb lobsters, 6 lbs grilled sliced filet mignon, roasted baby potatoes, sautéed seasonal vegetable, ciabatta bread, drawn butter, demi glace
0
Service ware
DEFRAGService ware $1.00
Bio-degradable plates, heavy duty forks, knives, spoons, napkins
0
Soup
Chicken Stew (GF) $6.00
Pulled chicken, veggies,hearty sofrito chicken broth.
0
Special Desserts
Mini Carrot Cake $3.95
all natural, no preservatives
0
Linda's Salted Caramel Espresso Bars $3.95
Espresso ganache, salted caramel, graham crust
0
Sangrias
Pavan White Sangria $6.50 - $23.00
Pavan (grape, orange blossom liqueur) pinot grigio, sliced granny smith apples, oranges, seltzer
0
Summer Red Sangria $6.50 - $23.00
Red wine, lemons, limes, oranges
0
Cocktails
Try our choice cocktails including dark & stormy, toasted coconut, orange cosmo, and pina colada.
Blue Hawaii Martini $9.00
pineapple infused vodka, blue curacao
0
Coconut Mojito $9.00
0
Wine
Marque de Riscal Sauvignon Blanc $7.50 - $26.00
French grape, Spanish vineyard. Fruit forward, long finish. Wonderful summer wine
0
Mini Desserts
Mini-Mousse $2.95
homemade chocolate mousse
0
Lil' Key Lime $2.95
zesty Key Lime pie
0
Strawberry "Shorty" Cake $2.95
fresh berries, pound cake, fresh whipped cream
0
Petite Trifle $2.95
ny cheesecake with raspberries
0
Summer Bread Pudding $2.95
white chocolate-blueberry bread pudding with rum-orange cream sauce
0
Red Velvet Cake $2.95
red velvet mini-cake
0
Full Desserts
Brownie Sundae $5.95
served warm ala mode with chocolate sauce and whipped cream. Yummy!
0
Kentucky Pie $5.95
layers of chocolate, peanuts, nougat and caramel in a graham cracker crust. Served warm
0
Apple Crisp $5.95
our own recipe, made with apples, cinnamon, brown sugar and delicious oatmeal "crisp"
0
Chocolate Mousse $5.95
everyone's favorite!
0
White Wines
Pinot Grigio, Ca Donini, Italy $24.00
0
Grüner Veltliner, Der Pollerhof, Austria $30.00
0
Chardonnay, Simply Naked, California $26.00
0
Chardonnay, Hess Select, California $29.00
0
Chardonnay, Sonoma-Cutrer, California $34.00
0
Sauvignon Blanc, Brancott, New Zealand $29.00
0
Riesling, Chateau Ste. Michelle, Washington $27.00
0
Pouilly Fuisse, JJ Vincent, France $38.00
0
White Zinfandel, Sycamore Lane, California $19.00
0
Red Wines
Merlot, 12' Two Vines, California $25.00
0
Malbec, 11' Graffigna, Argentina $29.00
0
Cabernet Sauvignon, 11' Ravenswood, California $28.00
0
Cabernet Sauvignon, 10' Girasole, California $30.00
Certified Organic
0
Pinot Noir, 09' Blackstone, California $29.00
0
Carignano Del Sulcis, 08' Sardinia $33.00
0
Taste Red, 10' Bedell, Long Island $45.00
0
Vacqueyras, 10' Domaine de Chantegut, France $44.00
0
Falerno del massico, 08' Campania, Italy $49.00
0
Sparkling Wines
Marquis de la Tour, Brut, France $24.00
0
Frexinet "Split" Brut, Spain $8.00
0

* Disclaimer: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

Hot Menus

Total Price