Menu With Price Menu Old Mill Restaurant Menu

Old Mill Restaurant Menu and Prices

4.5 based on 86 votes

Choose My State

Appetizers

Begin your meal with one of these tasty options

French Onion Soup	$6.50	Served in a crock, topped with crispy croutons and smothered in melted cheese MORE
Stuffed Mushrooms	$8.95	Served in a skillet and stuffed with our special sausage stuffing MORE
Shrimp Cocktail	$9.45	5 large shrimp, chilled and served with a tasty cocktail sauce MORE
Soup and Salad - (As a meal, without purchase of entree)	$12.95	All you can eat. Includes soup of the day, home baked bread, and fresh garden salad with a selection of homemade dressings MORE

Dinner Selections

All dinners include: Family-style servings of our homemade Soup of the Day and our Garden Salad with a selection of dressings, home baked bread, plus your choice of baked potato, steak fries, rice pilaf, or broccoli. Substitute French Onion Soup for soup of the day for $2.95 more.

Stuffed Chicken Breast	0	$24.95	Stuffed with a spinach and cheese stuffing, lightly breaded and covered with a delightful white sauce MORE
Barbeque Platter	0	$26.95	Pork ribs and chicken, slow cooked and slathered in our delicious barbeque sauce MORE
Shepherd's Pie	0	$23.95	A large portion of sautéed beef in a brown sauce with corn, topped with home style mashed potatoes MORE
Roast Long Island Duckling	0	$26.95	Covered with our delicious Bing cherry sauce MORE
Stuffed Pork Chops	0	$24.95	Two large bone-in chops with a tasty bread and bacon stuffing, covered with a flavorful brown sauce MORE
Au Gratin	0	$24.95	Potatoes, tomatoes, summer squash and pancetta blended with cream and fresh herbs, then topped with Monterey Jack and baked. MORE

Thai Gratin	0	$24.95	Eggplant, tomatoes, summer squash and campanelle pasta blended with red Thai curry and coconut milk, then topped with Monterey Jack and baked. MORE

Steak Selections

Roast Prime Rib of Beef (au jus)	$30.95	A large tender cut of prime beef cooked to your specifications, served in its natural juices. End cuts medium to well. Limited availability MORE
New York Strip Steak	$29.95	A generous cut of NY strip steak charbroiled to perfection MORE
Delmonico Steak	$30.95	A large cut of choice ribeye steak, charbroiled to perfection MORE
Filet Mignon	$31.95	A tender aged cut of prime beef, charbroiled to perfection and topped with sauteed mushrooms MORE
Bearnaise Sauce	$1.00	Add a side of Bearnaise Sauce to complement any steak entree MORE

Seafood Entrees

Salmon Florentine	0	$24.95	A generous portion of broiled salmon served over a bed of spinach and topped with a cream cheese and dill sauce MORE
Fresh Fillet of Fish	0	$19.95	Your choice of deep fried to a golden brown or broiled MORE
Broiled Boston Scrod	0	$22.95	Tender baby codfish broiled in our seasoned bread crumbs MORE
Gulf Shrimp	0	$26.95	Breaded and deep fried to a golden brown, or our own Shrimp Scampi recipe MORE

Sea Scallops	0	$28.95	Breaded and deep fried to a golden brown, or our own Scallop Scampi recipe MORE
Scallops Au Gratin	0	$28.95	Sea scallops baked en casserole in a delicate cheese sauce MORE
Fried Seafood Platter	0	$27.95	A generous portion of clams, scallops, shrimp, cod, and a crab cake, breaded and deep fried to a golden brown MORE
Broiled Seafood Platter	0	$28.95	Scallops, shrimp, cod and a petite lobster tail, broiled in wine and butter and lightly seasoned MORE
Snow Crab Legs	0	$30.95	One and a half pounds of Snow Crab legs served with drawn butter MORE
Broiled Lobster Tails	0	$	Two large succulent 6 oz. tails, served with drawn butter MORE

Pasta Entrees

Creamy Garlic Penne Pasta	0	$21.95	Penne pasta tossed with sauteed mushrooms in a creamy garlic sauce. Topped with fresh diced tomatoes. MORE
Homemade Macaroni and Cheese	0	$19.95	Penne pasta in a creamy three-cheese sauce, topped with panko bread crumbs and baked to perfection. MORE

Starters

House Salad	0	$3.50	Served with your choice of dressing MORE
Soup Of The Day	0	$3.95

Crock of French Onion Soup	0	$6.50	Topped with crispy croutons and smothered with melted cheese. MORE
10 Chicken Wings	0	$9.95	Mild, medium or hot, served with blue cheese and celery. MORE
Shrimp Cocktail	0	$9.45	5 large shrimp, chilled and served with a tasty cocktail sauce. MORE
Stuffed Mushrooms	0	$8.95	Served in a skillet and stuffed with our special sausage stuffing. MORE
Chicken Tenders	0	$9.95	Served with your choice of fries. MORE

Sandwiches and Burgers

Served with curly, sweet potato or steak fries.

French Dip Sandwich	0	$11.45	Thinly shaved prime rib on a baguette with melted provolone and a side of au jus. MORE
Grilled Chicken Sandwich	0	$10.25	Your choice of bbq, honey mustard, teriyaki or buffalo style. Served with lettuce, tomato and onion. MORE
"Run of The Mill" Burger	0	$9.95	1/2 lb. burger served with lettuce, tomato, onion and your choice of cheese. MORE
Southwest Veggie Burger	0	$9.95	Black bean and salsa patty topped with lettuce, tomato, onion and a choice of cheese. MORE
Reuben Sandwich	0	$10.95	Lean corned beef on marbled rye, grilled with Swiss cheese, fresh sauerkraut and 1000 Islands dressing. MORE

BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich	0	$9.95	Slow-roasted pork, shredded and smothered in our homemade barbecue sauce. MORE
Fish Sandwich	0	$8.95	Deep fried to a golden brown and topped with lettuce, tomato and onion. MORE

Salads

Caesar Salad	$9.95	A classic with romaine lettuce, creamy dressing and croutons. MORE
Salmon Salad	$14.95	Herb grilled salmon served over a bed of mixed greens with goats milk cheese, tomato, red onion, sliced almonds and maple dressing. MORE
Wedge Salad	$9.95	Fresh crispy iceberg wedge with bacon, tomato, red onion and homemade blue cheese dressing. MORE

Pizza

Florentine Pizza	0	$10.95	12 inch thin crust topped with tomatoes, spinach, cherry peppers and mozzarella cheese. MORE
Pepperoni Pizza	0	$10.95	12 inch thin crust topped with our homemade marinara and mozzarella cheese, topped with pepperoni. MORE

Other Favorites

Creamy Garlic Penne Pasta	0	$14.95	Penne pasta tossed with sauteed mushrooms in a creamy garlic sauce. Topped with fresh diced tomatoes. MORE
Fillet of Fish	0	$11.95	Fresh fish deep fried to a golden brown or broiled. Served with coleslaw and your choice of fries. MORE

Children's Entrees

All kids meals include a beverage and choice of fries, baked potato, rice pilaf or broccoli, plus a beverage.

Chicken Tenders	0	$7.95 - $9.95

Kraft Macaroni and Cheese	0	$7.95 - $9.95
Hamburger or Cheeseburger	0	$7.95 - $9.95
Pasta with butter, marinara, or alfredo sauce	0	$7.95 - $9.95
Grilled Cheese Sandwich	0	$7.95 - $9.95
Pizza - Cheese or Pepperoni	0	$7.95 - $9.95
NY Strip Steak	0	$11.95 - $13.95
All You Can Eat Soup and Salad	0	$6.95	Unlimited Soup of the Day and Garden Salad (Without meal purchase) MORE

Desserts

Wrap up your meal with a sweet treat

Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie	0	$5.75	Chocolate cookie crust topped with a layer of fudge and a luscious peanut butter filling. MORE
Key Lime Pie	0	$5.50	Graham Cracker Crust filled with a tangy and sweet lime custard, topped with whipped cream. MORE
Fruits of the Forest Pie	0	$5.50	Flaky pie crust filled with tender and juicy apples, strawberries, raspberries, blackberries and rhubarb. MORE

New York Cheesecake	0	$5.50 - $5.95	Rich and creamy cheesecake with a graham cracker crust. MORE
Lemon Layer Cake	0	$5.75	Light and refreshing sponge cake layered with lemon cream filling and Meyer lemon curd. MORE
Chocolate Tuxedo Cake	0	$6.25	Chocolate cake topped with layers of milk chocolate and white chocolate mousse, inside a chocolate shell. MORE
Strawberry Shortcake	0	$6.25	Flaky buttermilk biscuits layered with juicy strawberries and whipped cream. MORE
Sundaes	0	$5.75	Vanilla ice cream with your choice of strawberry or chocolate topping, finished off with whipped cream and a cherry. MORE

Signature Cocktails

Melontini	$8.50	A tasty twist on a classic cocktail. Watermelon Vodka, Midori Melon Liqueur, and a splash of Triple Sec served straight up in a martini glass. Garnished with a wedge of candied watermelon. MORE
Dark and Stormy	$7.50	A refreshing blend of Gosling's Black Seal Bermuda Rum, Saranac Ginger Beer, and a splash of Rose's Lime Juice. Served over ice in a tall glass, garnished with a lime wedge. MORE
Creamsicle	$7.50	A sinfully delicious blend of Orange Cream Vodka, Half and Half, and a splash of Orange Juice. Served over ice with an orange wedge. MORE
Parrot Bay Sunset	$7.25	Parrot Bay Coconut Rum paired with Cranberry Juice and Orange Juice. Served in a tall glass with a lime wedge. Perfect while enjoying an Adirondack Sunset! MORE
Parrot Head Margarita	$8.50	Straight out of Margaritaville! Served over ice in a salt-rimmed glass, this classic cocktail is sure to please any Jimmy Buffett fan. MORE
Melonberry Madness	$8.00	A fruity delight made with Watermelon and Raspberry Vodkas, Cranberry Juice, Triple Sec and a splash of Sierra Mist. Garnished with a lime wedge. MORE
Pickled Mary	$8.50	Our Signature Bloody Mary, served in a pint glass. Garnished to the nines with a stalk of celery and an assortment of tasty pickled treats. MORE

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.