Menu With Price Menu Carmella's Pizzeria Middletown Menu

Carmella's Pizzeria Middletown Menu and Prices

3.9 based on 120 votes

Choose My State

Beverages

Beverage

20 oz. Soda	0	$1.79
Juice	0	$1.89
Vitamin Water	0	$1.99
Powerade	0	$1.99
Yoohoo	0	$1.89

Appetizers

Appetizer

6 Mozzarella Sticks	0	$7.39	Baked golden brown and served with a side of marinara sauce. MORE
Chicken Wings	0	$8.99	Includes 10-12 wings baked to perfection, served plain, spicy, teriyaki, BBQ, honey BBQ or east-west (a tasty combination of BBQ and teriyaki) with your choice of ranch or blue cheese. MORE
Chicken Tenders	0	$8.29	Half a pound of wings baked to perfection, served plain, spicy, teriyaki, BBQ, honey BBQ or east-west (a tasty combination of BBQ and teriyaki) with your choice of ranch or blue cheese. MORE
12" Garlic Bread	0	$2.99	Mouth watering garlic bread served with a side of our homemade basil marinara sauce. MORE
4 Cheese Garlic Bread	0	$4.79	Mozzarella, Parmesan, crumbled blue cheese and goat cheese. MORE

Oven Baked Bread Strips	0	$6.99	Roasted garlic foccacia bread with marinara dipping sauce. MORE
Meatballs	0	$6.39	A side of three homemade meatballs smothered in basil marinara sauce. MORE

Salads

Salad

House Salad	0	$9.95	Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, croutons and banana pepper rings. MORE
Antipasto Salad	0	$9.95	Pepperoni, salami, ham, provolone, artichokes and croutons. Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, cro MORE
Chef Salad	0	$9.95	Ham, turkey, American cheese, artichokes and hard boiled egg. Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, c MORE
Oven Roasted Chicken Salad	0	$9.95	Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, croutons and banana pepper rings. MORE
Caesar Salad	0	$9.95	Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, croutons and banana pepper rings. MORE
Chicken Caesar Salad	0	$9.95	Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, croutons and banana pepper rings. MORE
Spicy Shrimp Salad	0	$9.95	Roasted shrimp with Cajun spices served with mixed greens. Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, crou MORE
Apricot Chicken Marmalade Salad	0	$9.95	Baked chicken glazed with apricot marmalade and roasted almonds. Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives MORE

Oven Dried Steak and Gorgonzola Salad	0	$9.95	Caramelized pineapple and honey roasted sour apples. Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, croutons a MORE
Albacore Tuna Salad	0	$9.95	Seasoned tuna, sliced red onion, cilantro and capers. Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, croutons MORE
Buffalo Ranch Chicken Salad	0	$9.95	Baked chicken breast golden brown and tossed with Buffalo ranch dressing. Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, bla MORE
Greek Salad	0	$9.95	Served with artichokes and feta cheese. Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, croutons and banana pep MORE
Dijon Chicken Salad	0	$9.95	Baked chicken breast, Dijon ranch, cilantro, basil and shaved prosciutto. Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, bla MORE
Rosemary Ginger Shrimp Salad	0	$9.95	Roasted garlic and fresh lemon. Caramella's salads are made fresh to order. Special blend of romaine and green leaf lettuce. Includes carrots, cucumbers, black olives, croutons and banana pepper ring MORE

Specialty Pizza

Carmella's Pizza	0	$13.29 - $20.29	Fresh basil, mascarpone, goat cheese and Parmesan. Topped with red sauce and mozzarella. MORE
Meateater Pizza	0	$13.29 - $20.29	Pepperoni, sausage, chourico, ham, bacon and meatballs. Topped with red sauce and mozzarella. MORE
Veggie Pizza	0	$13.29 - $20.29	Broccoli, spinach, mushrooms, tomatoes, onions, peppers and black olives. Topped with red sauce and mozzarella. MORE
Hawaiian Pizza	0	$13.29 - $20.29	Ham, pineapple and extra mozzarella. Topped with red sauce and mozzarella. MORE

Prosciutto Popeye Pizza	0	$13.29 - $20.29	Prosciutto, spinach, broccoli, roasted garlic and Parmesan. Topped with red sauce and mozzarella. MORE
House Special Pizza	0	$13.29 - $20.29	Pepperoni, sausage, chourico, bacon, peppers, mushrooms, onions and black olives. Topped with red sauce and mozzarella. MORE
Pesto Shrimp Pizza	0	$13.29 - $20.29	Sweet shrimp, pesto, red onion, tomato and mascarpone. Topped with red sauce and mozzarella. MORE
Pesto Sweet Sausage Pizza	0	$13.29 - $20.29	Sweet Italian sausage, pesto, goat cheese and caramelized onions. Topped with red sauce and mozzarella. MORE
Pesto Chicken Pizza	0	$13.29 - $20.29	Baked chicken, pesto, sun-dried tomatoes, and mushrooms. Topped with red sauce and mozzarella. MORE

Specialty White Pizzas

Specialty White Pizza

White Pizza	0	$13.29 - $20.29	Garlic oil, feta, goat, mascarpone, Parmesan along with mozzarella. Served brushed with garlic oil and mozzarella. MORE
BLT Pizza	0	$13.29 - $20.29	Garlic oil, crumbled bacon, with garlic butter and mozzarella cooked then topped with lettuce, tomatoes and mayonnaise. Served brushed with garlic oil and mozzarella. MORE
Steak and Cheese Pizza	0	$13.29 - $20.29	Garlic oil, American cheese, shaved steak, cooked mushrooms, caramelized onions and roasted peppers. Served brushed with garlic oil and mozzarella. MORE
Steak Bomb Pizza	0	$13.29 - $20.29	Garlic oil, American cheese, shaved steak, cooked mushrooms, caramelized onions, crumbled blue cheese and hot sauce. Served brushed with garlic oil and mozzarella. MORE
Spanikopita Pizza	0	$13.29 - $20.29	Brushed with garlic oil and loaded with spinach and feta cheese and Parmesan. Served brushed with garlic oil and mozzarella. MORE

Rosemary Chicken Pizza	0	$13.29 - $20.29	Garlic oil, baked chicken, roasted garlic, feta cheese, tomatoes and rosemary. Served brushed with garlic oil and mozzarella. MORE
Spicy Chicken Pizza	0	$13.29 - $20.29	Baked chicken, Buffalo ranch sauce, hot sauce, crumbled blue cheese and fresh cilantro. Served brushed with garlic oil and mozzarella. MORE
BBQ Chicken Pizza	0	$13.29 - $20.29	BBQ sauce, baked chicken, red onion and tomatoes. Served brushed with garlic oil and mozzarella. MORE
Buffalo Chicken Pizza	0	$13.29 - $20.29	Our own Buffalo ranch sauce, baked chicken, red onions, crumbled blue cheese, banana peppers and fresh cilantro. Served brushed with garlic oil and mozzarella. MORE

Pizza the Traditional Way

Cheese Pizza

$9.19 - $12.49

Calzones

Calzone

Calzone	0	$9.29	Stuffed with a mixture of ricotta, mozzarella, Parmesan, provolone and red sauce, baked to perfection then brushed with garlic oil and dashed with Parmesan served with a side of homemade marinara. MORE
Specialty Calzone	0	$12.95	Turn a specialty pizza into a calzone. Stuffed with a mixture of ricotta, mozzarella, Parmesan, provolone and red sauce, baked to perfection then brushed with garlic oil and dashed with Parmesan serv MORE

Specialty Wraps

Specialty Wrap

Steak Bomb Wrap	0	$8.89	Shaved steak, onions, mushrooms, hot sauce, blue cheese, American cheese and tomato. MORE
Chicken Caesar Wrap	0	$8.89	Oven roasted chicken, Parmesan, provolone, romaine, tomatoes, crisp bacon and Caesar dressing. MORE
Spicy Shrimp Wrap	0	$8.89	Sweet shrimp, Cajun spice, tamari, cilantro, banana pepper, provolone, tomatoes, lettuce and hot sauce. MORE

Buffalo Ranch Chicken Wrap	0	$8.89	Oven baked breaded tenders, provolone, goat cheese, tomatoes and Buffalo ranch. MORE
Balsamic Chicken Wrap	0	$8.89	Balsamic marinated chicken, cucumbers, feta cheese, red onions, tomatoes and provolone. MORE
Hawaiian Wrap	0	$8.89	Baked ham, caramelized pineapple, mozzarella cheese, roasted peppers and sliced red onion. MORE
East West Teriyaki Chicken Wrap	0	$8.89	Roasted chicken breast, candied onions, spinach, provolone and tomato. MORE
Greek Wrap	0	$8.89	The favorites from the salad with provolone, spinach and Greek dressing chicken marmalade - baked chicken, lettuce, tomato, provolone, almonds, apricots and honey mustard. MORE

Pasta

Marinara	0	$12.99	Homemade marinara infused with roasted garlic, fresh basil and spices. Topped with Parmesan and basil. MORE
Marinara with Homemade Meatballs	0	$12.99	Our homemade meatballs. Topped with Parmesan and basil. MORE
Marinara with Homemade Sausage	0	$12.99	Plump sweet Italian sausage links. Topped with Parmesan and basil. MORE
Chicken Prosciutto	0	$12.99	Pasta tossed with prosciutto, chicken, spinach, roasted garlic, diced tomatoes, and broccoli and in a chicken basil olive oil broth. Topped with Parmesan and basil. MORE
Eggplant Parmigiana	0	$12.99	Baked breaded eggplant, mozzarella and marinara. Topped with Parmesan and basil. MORE

Sweet Shrimp	0	$12.99	Pasta with oven roasted shrimp, sweet peppers, tomatoes and mushrooms in a mascarpone rose marinara sauce. Topped with Parmesan and basil. MORE
Baked Stuffed Shells	0	$12.99	Four jumbo shells stuffed with ricotta and fresh herbs topped with marinara and mozzarella. Topped with Parmesan and basil. MORE
Chicken Parmigiana	0	$12.99	Baked breaded chicken, mozzarella and marinara. Topped with Parmesan and basil. MORE
Penne Baked with 4 Cheeses	0	$12.99	Mozzarella, Parmesan, ricotta and mascarpone. Tossed and oven baked. Topped with Parmesan and basil. MORE

Wraps

Wrap

Italian Cold Cut Wrap	0	$8.29	Genoa, ham, cooked salami, pepperoni and provolone. MORE
Turkey Breast Wrap	0	$8.29	Sliced white meat and provolone. MORE
Ham and Cheese Wrap	0	$8.29	Baked ham and provolone. MORE
Roast Beef Wrap	0	$8.29	Sliced paper thin and topped with provolone. MORE
Tuna Wrap	0	$8.29	Albacore tuna with a touch of mayonnaise and provolone. MORE
Veggie Wrap	0	$8.29	Tomato, olives, onion, green peppers, mushrooms, spinach, broccoli and provolone cheese. MORE

Steak and Cheese Wrap	0	$8.29	Served with mushroom, onions and American cheese. MORE
Meatball Wrap	0	$8.29	Homemade and topped with our own marinara sauce and provolone. MORE
Meatball and Sausage Combo Wrap	0	$8.29	With sweet Italian sausage with meatballs. Homemade and topped with our own marinara sauce and provolone. MORE
Sausage and Peppers Wrap	0	$8.29	Sausage and sweet peppers with marinara and provolone. MORE
Chicken Parmigiana Wrap	0	$8.29	Baked breaded tenders, our own marinara sauce and provolone. MORE
Eggplant Parmigiana Wrap	0	$8.29	Baked breaded eggplant, our own marinara sauce and provolone. MORE
Chourico Wrap	0	$8.29	Baked with onions, peppers, marinara and provolone. MORE
Chicken Cutlet Wrap	0	$8.29	Baked breaded chicken tenders, lettuce, tomato and provolone. MORE
BLT Wrap	0	$8.29	Crisp bacon, lettuce and tomato. MORE
Hamburger	0	$8.29	Black Angus burger cooked medium well for safety served with your choice of cheese. MORE

Pastrami Wrap	0	$8.29	Flavorful black pastrami served with melted Swiss cheese. MORE

Grinders

Grinder

Italian Cold Cut Grinder	0	$7.39 - $8.29	Genoa, ham, cooked salami, pepperoni and provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese. MORE
Turkey Breast Grinder	0	$7.39 - $8.29	Sliced white meat and provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese. MORE
Ham and Cheese Grinder	0	$7.39 - $8.29	Baked ham and provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese. MORE
Roast Beef Grinder	0	$7.39 - $8.29	Sliced paper thin and topped with provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese. MORE
Tuna Grinder	0	$7.39 - $8.29	Albacore tuna with a touch of mayonnaise and provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese. MORE
Veggie Grinder	0	$7.39 - $8.29	Tomato, olives, onion, green peppers, mushrooms, spinach, broccoli and provolone cheese. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese. MORE
Steak and Cheese Grinder	0	$7.39 - $8.29	Served with mushroom, onions and American cheese. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese. MORE
Meatball Grinder	0	$7.39 - $8.29	Homemade and topped with our own marinara sauce and provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese. MORE
Meatball and Sausage Combo Grinder	0	$7.39 - $8.29	Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese. MORE

Sausage and Peppers Grinder	0	$7.39 - $8.29	Sausage and sweet peppers with marinara and provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese. MORE
Chicken Parmigiana Grinder	0	$7.39 - $8.29	Baked breaded tenders, our own marinara sauce and provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese. MORE
Eggplant Parmigiana Grinder	0	$7.39 - $8.29	Baked breaded eggplant, our own marinara sauce and provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese. MORE
Chourico Grinder	0	$7.39 - $8.29	Baked with onions, peppers, marinara and provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese. MORE
Chicken Cutlet Grinder	0	$7.39 - $8.29	Baked breaded chicken tenders, lettuce, tomato and provolone. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese. MORE
BLT Grinder	0	$7.39 - $8.29	Crisp bacon, lettuce and tomato. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese. MORE
Hamburger	0	$7.39 - $8.29	Black Angus burger cooked medium well for safety served with your choice of cheese. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese. MORE
12" Pastrami Grinder	0	$8.29	Flavorful black pastrami served with melted Swiss cheese. Includes lettuce and tomato and are served warm with melted cheese. MORE

Chips

Chip

Chips

$1.00

Your choice of flavor.

Extras

Extra

4 oz. Salad Dressing	0	$0.99

4 oz. Homemade Marinara	0	$1.99
Cheese	0	$1.59
Bacon	0	$1.79
1/2 lb. Shrimp	0	$3.99
1/2 lb. Chicken	0	$2.99

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.